[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"sanity-fyWcDVWJAtuz3miI4jbffLqYS8FVJyW4HmqVRlA0dtg":3,"sanity-LCq5ZsBfyJf6DvIJMYIRtWNbSCv5rCThSB1qAXbaTBI":4138},{"data":4,"sourceMap":-1},{"latestPodcast":5,"latestReleases":14,"post":39,"recent":4113},[6],{"_id":7,"publishedAt":8,"slug":9,"sponsored":12,"title":13},"5c7f0882-e1a7-4d0e-9e06-86cce9c3613a","2026-07-02T07:40:00.000Z",{"_type":10,"current":11},"slug","ai-coding-chaos-into-a-repeatable-playbook",null,"How do you turn AI coding chaos into a repeatable playbook?",[15,21,27,33],{"_id":16,"publishedAt":17,"slug":18,"title":20},"eb5b66eb-9410-4329-83bb-22bbff39402a","2026-04-28T13:00:00.000Z",{"_type":10,"current":19},"turn-scattered-knowledge-into-trusted-intelligence","Turning scattered knowledge into trusted intelligence: Stack Internal 2026.3",{"_id":22,"publishedAt":23,"slug":24,"title":26},"369c2401-b62e-4a37-8ff8-bf603023ecad","2026-03-02T15:03:00.988Z",{"_type":10,"current":25},"what-s-new-at-stack-overflow-march-2026","What’s new at Stack Overflow: March 2026",{"_id":28,"publishedAt":29,"slug":30,"title":32},"5e9053a4-07ea-447c-91ea-29e0b6228537","2026-02-02T15:00:00.000Z",{"_type":10,"current":31},"what-s-new-at-stack-overflow-february-2026","What’s new at Stack Overflow: February 2026",{"_id":34,"publishedAt":35,"slug":36,"title":38},"a1b538eb-a8a6-46d0-80a1-ac70ec9bb935","2026-01-05T10:00:00.000-05:00",{"_type":10,"current":37},"what-s-new-at-stack-overflow-january-2026","What’s new at Stack Overflow: January 2026",{"_createdAt":40,"_id":41,"_rev":42,"_type":43,"_updatedAt":44,"author":12,"body":45,"dateUrl":4074,"excerpt":4075,"image":4076,"product":12,"publishedAt":4081,"slug":4082,"sponsored":12,"tags":4084,"title":4111,"visible":4112},"2023-06-07T14:30:32Z","labs-342a7b47-11fa-4ec6-ac3c-1dd74b466e6b","1Ux0qERz9gT278a6RW8mnF","blogPost","2025-09-24T11:54:58Z",[46,57,90,98,106,114,124,132,140,148,156,164,173,181,189,198,227,235,243,251,260,268,276,283,517,525,533,541,549,556,604,612,620,628,635,652,660,668,675,744,752,780,787,795,803,811,827,834,842,850,857,987,994,1002,1009,1040,1047,1055,1097,1105,1112,1120,1128,1136,1144,1152,1160,1184,1191,1199,1207,1215,1222,1356,1364,1371,1379,1387,1394,1426,1433,1441,1449,1456,1499,1507,1515,1523,1531,1538,1546,1554,1571,1578,1586,1593,1688,1695,1703,1710,1732,1740,1748,1756,1763,1793,1801,1808,1816,1824,1832,1840,1859,1867,1878,1886,1898,1906,1918,1926,1938,1946,1958,1966,1979,1987,1999,2007,2020,2027,2035,2042,2139,2146,2242,2249,2343,2350,2457,2464,2560,2567,2653,2660,2742,2749,2830,2837,2917,2924,2932,2939,2960,2967,2987,2994,3016,3023,3044,3051,3069,3076,3102,3109,3130,3137,3156,3163,3184,3191,3199,3207,3215,3222,3248,3255,3284,3291,3321,3328,3357,3364,3394,3401,3429,3436,3462,3469,3494,3501,3526,3533,3541,3548,3556,3564,3571,3587,3594,3604,3611,3621,3628,3639,3646,3657,3664,3673,3680,3691,3698,3710,3717,3727,3734,3741,3748,3779,3786,3814,3821,3853,3860,3890,3897,3927,3934,3962,3969,4000,4007,4033,4040,4066],{"_key":47,"_type":48,"children":49,"markDefs":55,"style":56},"fe3fb1a9fff3","block",[50],{"_key":51,"_type":52,"marks":53,"text":54},"dd7781bd93110","span",[],"Introduction",[],"h2",{"_key":58,"_type":48,"children":59,"markDefs":83,"style":89},"e6e68d8d4945",[60,65,70,74,79],{"_key":61,"_type":52,"marks":62,"text":64},"d9c478a4b07d0",[63],"strong","In ",{"_key":66,"_type":52,"marks":67,"text":69},"d9c478a4b07d1",[68,63],"840bcb9764b3","March 2023",{"_key":71,"_type":52,"marks":72,"text":73},"d9c478a4b07d2",[63],", we found that developers were both curious and skeptical about AI. With our ",{"_key":75,"_type":52,"marks":76,"text":78},"5e8234a0f323",[63,77],"cbf21d46b3e9","2023 Developer Survey",{"_key":80,"_type":52,"marks":81,"text":82},"d054693d6422",[63],", we see that perception is still holding.",[84,87],{"_key":68,"_type":85,"href":86,"reference":12},"link","https:\u002F\u002Fstackoverflow.blog\u002F2023\u002F03\u002F09\u002Fafter-the-buzz-fades-what-our-data-tells-us-about-emerging-technology-sentiment\u002F",{"_key":77,"_type":85,"href":88,"reference":12},"https:\u002F\u002Fsurvey.stackoverflow.co\u002F2023\u002F","normal",{"_key":91,"_type":48,"children":92,"markDefs":97,"style":89},"eec637175537",[93],{"_key":94,"_type":52,"marks":95,"text":96},"ac9f999f2bb5",[],"This is a good thing. We support a healthy amount of skepticism as new things are rolled out—a new technology needs to be put through its paces before we know it’s ready for production.",[],{"_key":99,"_type":48,"children":100,"markDefs":105,"style":89},"a184744a5b8e",[101],{"_key":102,"_type":52,"marks":103,"text":104},"71d2f8131c210",[],"We explore the nuances in perceptions and the use of AI tools below.",[],{"_key":107,"_type":48,"children":108,"markDefs":113,"style":56},"f9b209186af8",[109],{"_key":110,"_type":52,"marks":111,"text":112},"2491ba38da4d0",[],"Highlights",[],{"_key":115,"_type":48,"children":116,"level":121,"listItem":122,"markDefs":123,"style":89},"74332300f6e6",[117],{"_key":118,"_type":52,"marks":119,"text":120},"b2380de1b208",[],"70% are already using or plan to use AI tools in their development process:",1,"bullet",[],{"_key":125,"_type":48,"children":126,"level":121,"listItem":122,"markDefs":131,"style":89},"72193b5d9200",[127],{"_key":128,"_type":52,"marks":129,"text":130},"58fc2709aeec",[],"44% use AI tools now and 26% plan to soon.",[],{"_key":133,"_type":48,"children":134,"level":121,"listItem":122,"markDefs":139,"style":89},"2ba8993260a2",[135],{"_key":136,"_type":52,"marks":137,"text":138},"dc2a3661bcb2",[],"77% feel favorable towards using AI tools as part of their development workflow—but we do see some differences between groups.",[],{"_key":141,"_type":48,"children":142,"level":121,"listItem":122,"markDefs":147,"style":89},"a62dabfdd620",[143],{"_key":144,"_type":52,"marks":145,"text":146},"0cc868f6ef25",[],"33% see increasing productivity as the most important benefit of using AI tools as part of a development workflow.",[],{"_key":149,"_type":48,"children":150,"level":121,"listItem":122,"markDefs":155,"style":89},"54b351b40c42",[151],{"_key":152,"_type":52,"marks":153,"text":154},"2e6583d1b954",[],"42% trust the accuracy of the output of AI tools used in their development workflow.",[],{"_key":157,"_type":48,"children":158,"markDefs":163,"style":56},"763dcc2afd20",[159],{"_key":160,"_type":52,"marks":161,"text":162},"519bc77e9a500",[],"Current use of AI tools",[],{"_key":165,"_type":48,"children":166,"markDefs":171,"style":172},"8d749606fa7d",[167],{"_key":168,"_type":52,"marks":169,"text":170},"41583661132c0",[],"Professional vs learning to code",[],"h3",{"_key":174,"_type":48,"children":175,"markDefs":180,"style":89},"e7401fda015d",[176],{"_key":177,"_type":52,"marks":178,"text":179},"e9faf3af0f0c0",[],"More people learning to code report using AI tool in their development process. While about 30% of professional developers say they aren’t using the tools now and they don’t plan to.",[],{"_key":182,"_type":48,"children":183,"markDefs":188,"style":89},"502120d59a37",[184],{"_key":185,"_type":52,"marks":186,"text":187},"13ff3fcaf559",[],"This is where we see developer's curious and skeptical nature start to play out. Folks learning to code see the value of AI tools, likely because it can help them learn faster (more on this below). Professional developers are more cautious, likely because they’ve been through a couple of tech hype cycles before and want to see proof before they decide on the value to them.",[],{"_key":190,"_type":48,"children":191,"markDefs":197,"style":89},"57f090f21627",[192],{"_key":193,"_type":52,"marks":194,"text":196},"ae434a51ba7c0",[195],"em","Do you currently use AI tools in your development process?",[],{"_key":199,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":201},"d338e880bc54","table",[202,211,219],{"_key":203,"_type":204,"cells":205},"c39c2a73-e48d-45c1-b46e-354c5a3e6af9","tableRow",[206,207,208,209,210],"","Yes","No, but I plan to soon","No, and I don't plan to","Sum: Use or plan on using",{"_key":212,"_type":204,"cells":213},"b560f919-4897-4293-9640-8e86a169747c",[214,215,216,217,218],"Professional Developers","44.2% ","25.9%","30.0%","70.1%",{"_key":220,"_type":204,"cells":221},"c2d9c691-3fb4-43dc-a951-3632b7ef8ad1",[222,223,224,225,226],"Learning to Code","54.9%","27.4%","17.7%","82.3%",{"_key":228,"_type":48,"children":229,"markDefs":234,"style":172},"0a21f4dc05cb",[230],{"_key":231,"_type":52,"marks":232,"text":233},"9736789c31a30",[],"Professional developers by developer type",[],{"_key":236,"_type":48,"children":237,"markDefs":242,"style":89},"7d42b704ede1",[238],{"_key":239,"_type":52,"marks":240,"text":241},"8e25ebb15df60",[],"But…professional developers aren’t a homogeneous group, we see plenty of differences in use of AI tools and intent to use AI tools once we look past the surface.",[],{"_key":244,"_type":48,"children":245,"markDefs":250,"style":89},"6c8575ae9f29",[246],{"_key":247,"_type":52,"marks":248,"text":249},"be6cc1aa84060",[],"Developers focused on hardware, backend systems, or applications are less likely to be using AI tools now. This same group doesn’t see themselves using these tools in the future either.",[],{"_key":252,"_type":48,"children":253,"markDefs":258,"style":259},"07aff3af3a2b",[254],{"_key":255,"_type":52,"marks":256,"text":257},"868f9a6566c9",[],"This make sense—these developers build and work within complex systems, things we know that AI tools aren’t able to handle just yet.",[],"blockquote",{"_key":261,"_type":48,"children":262,"markDefs":267,"style":89},"7bd2c482f0ef",[263],{"_key":264,"_type":52,"marks":265,"text":266},"11942cc82e530",[],"Data scientists, front-end, fullstack, and cloud infrastructure developers are more likely to be using the tools now.",[],{"_key":269,"_type":48,"children":270,"markDefs":275,"style":259},"4f90e14231f2",[271],{"_key":272,"_type":52,"marks":273,"text":274},"bb13fd8b9650",[],"Again, this makes sense. Existing AI tools can help with the systems and code that these groups use regularly.",[],{"_key":277,"_type":48,"children":278,"markDefs":282,"style":89},"a6f10037d449",[279],{"_key":280,"_type":52,"marks":281,"text":196},"5ac2f8f16ee1",[195],[],{"_key":284,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":285},"7f71c96b6bd7",[286,289,297,305,313,321,328,336,344,352,360,367,374,382,389,396,404,411,419,427,435,443,450,458,466,474,482,490,496,502,510],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":288},"d15df325-14cf-47d4-bc9f-ef8352209d03",[206,207,208,209,210],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":291},"9235ebec-33c1-43a5-ab1d-f8f5f2d05854",[292,293,294,295,296],"Academic researcher","47.3%","19.0%","33.7%","66.3%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":299},"d3ba625c-9976-4521-b8a3-c2da41487269",[300,301,302,303,304],"Blockchain","62.6%","20.6%","16.7%","83.2%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":307},"b278708b-22eb-4886-a650-1ddb59ee4523",[308,309,310,311,312],"Cloud infrastructure engineer","45.1%","23.5%","31.4%","68.6%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":315},"fb963488-1548-48d7-9370-76c3fd27c9c8",[316,317,318,319,320],"Data or business analyst","43.8%","25.6%","30.6%","69.4%",{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":323},"872fa991-975c-4f9b-bff5-e4163bdbe386",[324,325,326,319,327],"Data scientist or machine learning specialist","60.3%","21.1%","81.4%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":330},"578d1137-8028-41d3-965c-455820673022",[331,332,333,334,335],"Database administrator","28.3%","32.3%","39.4%","60.6%",{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":338},"225c8930-c2ee-4adf-97cb-6b7b9453edfc",[339,340,341,342,343],"Designer","38.1%","18.6%","43.3%","56.7%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":346},"076283e2-e46d-450d-be1f-29ffc28daf8e",[347,348,349,350,351],"DevOps specialist","44.8%","24.4%","30.8%","69.2%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":354},"38837e87-3389-457e-9896-607622c42d53",[355,356,357,358,359],"Developer Advocate","47.8%","30.4%","21.7%","78.2%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":362},"63be6b85-cbc5-4356-a60b-5764f073961b",[363,364,365,365,366],"Developer Experience","43.6%","28.2%","71.8%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":369},"fdc7b2cb-ab9d-40a2-9ea4-816c83e12e7b",[370,371,357,372,373],"Developer, QA or test","40.3%","29.3%","70.7%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":376},"3d2fb0e4-a984-4e51-84b2-bd9653383319",[377,378,379,380,381],"Developer, back-end","39.8%","27.0%","33.2%","66.8%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":384},"dfc4abcc-8e28-45cc-bbe1-92d2cf95e1ac",[385,386,332,387,388],"Developer, desktop or enterprise applications","27.5%","44.2%","55.8%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":391},"3bcd450a-7187-4655-851f-e583083b9df7",[392,216,393,394,395],"Developer, embedded applications or devices","22.5%","51.5%","48.4%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":398},"de4354ca-b146-4996-b3f2-3fc4e286a3de",[399,400,401,402,403],"Developer, front-end","51.3%","26.7%","22.0%","78.0%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":406},"7405a0f6-28c5-48f6-b1af-307abc18b1b8",[407,408,318,409,410],"Developer, full-stack","47.6%","26.9%","73.2%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":413},"2ccbd4e4-be6b-4a05-9a56-9bb56b51e63f",[414,415,416,417,418],"Developer, game or graphics","35.9%","20.2%","43.9%","56.1%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":421},"cfa6ce93-c73d-4f25-a1ce-aa1033c66f7f",[422,423,424,425,426],"Developer, mobile","43.1%","30.3%","26.6%","73.4%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":429},"a473490a-ef23-4caa-ae2c-210ed26df92e",[430,431,432,433,434],"Educator","49.5%","20.7%","29.7%","70.2%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":437},"356ae454-79fd-45a0-904f-80dab0733e28",[438,439,440,441,442],"Engineer, data","44.1%","28.7%","27.3%","72.8%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":445},"7e2668eb-e38a-4699-9394-2e4e9080e54b",[446,447,448,378,449],"Engineer, site reliability","37.6%","22.6%","60.2%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":452},"0619c605-c341-4463-a6bf-d8838fa3d597",[453,454,455,456,457],"Engineering manager","42.6%","31.1%","26.3%","73.7%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":460},"ede88c7f-aec8-42f7-b616-8d14c32e76ec",[461,462,463,464,465],"Hardware Engineer","25.0%","29.2%","45.8%","54.2%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":468},"1992cfd0-24ea-4640-9da6-e961c1e5ad9d",[469,470,471,472,473],"Product manager","45.0%","35.1%","19.9%","80.1%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":476},"d0556b05-a74e-446f-a853-929d8fd583a5",[477,478,479,480,481],"Project manager","41.3%","32.6%","26.1%","73.9%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":484},"94d17155-8b17-4ddf-a254-6b5ad1e24121",[485,486,487,488,489],"Research & Development role","36.3%","26.8%","37.0%","63.1%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":492},"0c1f6561-aa96-40e6-8c48-30a834d1b67c",[493,479,494,317,495],"Scientist","23.6%","56.2%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":498},"52f5eca6-5388-40b9-b862-c9da19a71e88",[499,500,456,447,501],"Security professional","36.1%","62.4%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":504},"1fe34044-3212-4f35-9d3f-0c41d688c7d2",[505,506,507,508,509],"Senior Executive (C-Suite, VP, etc.)","52.9%","26.5%","20.5%","79.4%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":512},"6ecd3b02-2f5e-46b7-83d7-f6f68fb0254d",[513,514,456,515,516],"System administrator","33.6%","40.1%","59.9%",{"_key":518,"_type":48,"children":519,"markDefs":524,"style":172},"5952d10f2630",[520],{"_key":521,"_type":52,"marks":522,"text":523},"ec2b5b8d2b910",[],"Professional developers by years of experience",[],{"_key":526,"_type":48,"children":527,"markDefs":532,"style":89},"91d1035cdcc0",[528],{"_key":529,"_type":52,"marks":530,"text":531},"606a3d1c78f10",[],"We see a significant difference in professional developers who are using or don’t plan on using AI tools when looking at their years of professional work experience.",[],{"_key":534,"_type":48,"children":535,"markDefs":540,"style":89},"d277f3b9f6c9",[536],{"_key":537,"_type":52,"marks":538,"text":539},"9e760cc0090d0",[],"Developers who are earlier in their careers (\u003C=5 years) are much more likely to be using AI tools now. As developer experience increases, their likelihood to be using AI tools now decreases and more developers start to say that they don’t plan on using them—with close to 40% of developers with more than 21+ years of experience saying they don’t plan on using these tools.",[],{"_key":542,"_type":48,"children":543,"markDefs":548,"style":259},"3f34e1860d6f",[544],{"_key":545,"_type":52,"marks":546,"text":547},"19b13f55d4530",[],"More experienced developers are typically working on more complex projects and\u002For code structures, things that AI tools aren’t able to help with right now.",[],{"_key":550,"_type":48,"children":551,"markDefs":555,"style":89},"fbcfc9a46cdd",[552],{"_key":553,"_type":52,"marks":554,"text":196},"67dbcdae52c70",[195],[],{"_key":557,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":558},"a339ee0b04b7",[559,562,569,576,583,591,597],{"_key":560,"_type":204,"cells":561},"ec851809-5fd0-4ffa-a3fc-020151b82037",[206,207,208,209,210],{"_key":563,"_type":204,"cells":564},"acfefb71-aa4a-4d19-9723-69590087290f",[565,566,310,567,568],"\u003C1 year experience","55.1%","21.4%","78.6%",{"_key":570,"_type":204,"cells":571},"13edca1e-96d2-492c-9861-8c22e5abf7c2",[572,400,573,574,575],"1-5 years experience","24.3%","24.5%","75.6%",{"_key":577,"_type":204,"cells":578},"922c3865-6a1c-4f53-a221-fe1d4801f3a3",[579,580,386,581,582],"6-10 years experience","42.3%","30.2%","69.8%",{"_key":584,"_type":204,"cells":585},"fb0e25de-4eb1-456a-99a8-e78caf88d0e6",[586,587,588,589,590],"11-15 years experience","39.5%","28.0%","32.5%","67.5%",{"_key":592,"_type":204,"cells":593},"563c63ae-1360-47ec-8221-fc922822a8df",[594,415,365,595,596],"16-20 years experience","36.0%","64.1%",{"_key":598,"_type":204,"cells":599},"102b41b0-6f73-43f5-b5a9-c8fa56d8c5f2",[600,581,601,602,603],"21+ years experience","27.7%","42.2%","57.9%",{"_key":605,"_type":48,"children":606,"markDefs":611,"style":172},"6c0c8fe98c65",[607],{"_key":608,"_type":52,"marks":609,"text":610},"671b505fa8470",[],"Professional developers and people management",[],{"_key":613,"_type":48,"children":614,"markDefs":619,"style":89},"9198e13fa8ab",[615],{"_key":616,"_type":52,"marks":617,"text":618},"3adaafbe523c0",[],"Professional developers who are also people managers are more likely to say they are using or plan on using AI tools than those that are individual contributors.",[],{"_key":621,"_type":48,"children":622,"markDefs":627,"style":259},"4d891c92e14b",[623],{"_key":624,"_type":52,"marks":625,"text":626},"0ba0f16bf4f20",[],"This may have to do with people managers also being concerned about their team’s productivity and skill development—two of the main benefits developers report from using AI tools (more on this below).",[],{"_key":629,"_type":48,"children":630,"markDefs":634,"style":89},"aba846be21ec",[631],{"_key":632,"_type":52,"marks":633,"text":196},"e07a537081680",[195],[],{"_key":636,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":637},"e622d7a41c61",[638,640,645],{"_key":560,"_type":204,"cells":639},[206,207,208,209,210],{"_key":563,"_type":204,"cells":641},[642,364,456,643,644],"Individual contributor","30.1%","69.9%",{"_key":570,"_type":204,"cells":646},[647,648,649,650,651],"People manager","46.5%","29.6%","23.9%","76.1%",{"_key":653,"_type":48,"children":654,"markDefs":659,"style":172},"ba91b08f3e72",[655],{"_key":656,"_type":52,"marks":657,"text":658},"382c2c6f664c0",[],"Professional developers and country",[],{"_key":661,"_type":48,"children":662,"markDefs":667,"style":89},"47fabf22608f",[663],{"_key":664,"_type":52,"marks":665,"text":666},"63325809a7bf0",[],"Professional developers from India, Brazil, and Poland are most likely to use or plan on using AI tools as part of their development workflow. UK, French, US, and German developers are more likely to say they don’t plan on using AI tools.",[],{"_key":669,"_type":48,"children":670,"markDefs":674,"style":89},"27536efb928c",[671],{"_key":672,"_type":52,"marks":673,"text":196},"7b1ea2758aee",[195],[],{"_key":676,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":677},"19974bdfa9bf",[678,680,685,690,697,704,711,719,724,731,738],{"_key":560,"_type":204,"cells":679},[206,207,208,209,210],{"_key":563,"_type":204,"cells":681},[682,602,650,683,684],"🇦🇺 Australia","33.9%","66.1%",{"_key":570,"_type":204,"cells":686},[687,688,689,402,403],"🇧🇷 Brazil","48.9%","29.1%",{"_key":691,"_type":204,"cells":692},"0d7825fb-a228-4c97-9aaf-bbbda147fa43",[693,694,695,455,696],"🇨🇦 Canada","41.8%","27.1%","68.9%",{"_key":698,"_type":204,"cells":699},"0065a013-7de0-46dd-9401-ff13464ee97d",[700,701,567,702,703],"🇫🇷 France","40.0%","38.5%","61.4%",{"_key":705,"_type":204,"cells":706},"8476165d-c066-42d7-926a-53e9d5088876",[707,708,709,500,710],"🇩🇪 Germany","41.2%","22.7%","63.9%",{"_key":712,"_type":204,"cells":713},"876f0a34-5e6c-4d6c-a023-e7dc9988faae",[714,715,716,717,718],"🇮🇳 India","46.1%","37.5%","16.5%","83.6%",{"_key":720,"_type":204,"cells":721},"cdf926c9-b6ef-472d-affb-132bba0c16f3",[722,348,723,295,296],"🇳🇱 Netherlands","21.5%",{"_key":725,"_type":204,"cells":726},"349aa314-460e-489e-b234-15c262a79295",[727,728,729,433,730],"🇵🇱 Poland","45.6%","24.7%","70.3%",{"_key":732,"_type":204,"cells":733},"5d2d8d30-365b-4097-ac63-cc812d911e40",[734,716,735,736,737],"🇬🇧 United Kingdom","23.8%","38.7%","61.3%",{"_key":739,"_type":204,"cells":740},"57499d74-d690-4a05-b16e-28f7687e4d10",[741,742,743,500,710],"🇺🇸 United States of America","39.3%","24.6%",{"_key":745,"_type":48,"children":746,"markDefs":751,"style":56},"30148da4d7f3",[747],{"_key":748,"_type":52,"marks":749,"text":750},"f23f00df4dec0",[],"Perception of AI tools",[],{"_key":753,"_type":48,"children":754,"markDefs":779,"style":89},"2a0416a9112e",[755,759,763,767,771,775],{"_key":756,"_type":52,"marks":757,"text":758},"eb491b7e79c9",[63],"Favorable",{"_key":760,"_type":52,"marks":761,"text":762},"e1a89f763c3a",[]," = Very & Favorable\n",{"_key":764,"_type":52,"marks":765,"text":766},"b0d15898302f",[63],"Indifferent",{"_key":768,"_type":52,"marks":769,"text":770},"1912b1061670",[]," = Indifferent & Unsure\n",{"_key":772,"_type":52,"marks":773,"text":774},"1552f1e97ece",[63],"Unfavorable",{"_key":776,"_type":52,"marks":777,"text":778},"46169ca66fe1",[]," = Very & Unfavorable",[],{"_key":781,"_type":48,"children":782,"markDefs":786,"style":172},"c1ae4508ee66",[783],{"_key":784,"_type":52,"marks":785,"text":170},"0cab70c47e210",[],[],{"_key":788,"_type":48,"children":789,"markDefs":794,"style":89},"13e0cf84d13f",[790],{"_key":791,"_type":52,"marks":792,"text":793},"3b5751f1b7060",[],"Professional developers and those learning to code have similar favorable views of using AI tools as part of their workflow.",[],{"_key":796,"_type":48,"children":797,"markDefs":802,"style":259},"c62d562199c4",[798],{"_key":799,"_type":52,"marks":800,"text":801},"1114f9a4d91b",[],"The indifferent\u002Funsure and unfavorable group is where are our skeptics are—we’ll see more how these perceptions line up with the developers who say they don’t plan on using AI tools as part of their workflow.",[],{"_key":804,"_type":48,"children":805,"markDefs":810,"style":89},"0f48c6b1a960",[806],{"_key":807,"_type":52,"marks":808,"text":809},"6f66627aae180",[195],"How favorable is your stance on using AI tools as part of your development workflow?",[],{"_key":812,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":813},"0782dc1d2750",[814,817,823],{"_key":815,"_type":204,"cells":816},"34b697d3-e07c-4213-a93b-1d0aaf1becfc",[206,758,766,774],{"_key":818,"_type":204,"cells":819},"eb22d4fd-e49f-48e1-857f-3cbdd9940287",[214,820,821,822],"77.3%","19.7%","3.0%",{"_key":824,"_type":204,"cells":825},"79a159c2-2114-454a-a0c2-b1c37c7b4563",[222,651,432,826],"3.2%",{"_key":828,"_type":48,"children":829,"markDefs":833,"style":172},"8278fbe07c80",[830],{"_key":831,"_type":52,"marks":832,"text":233},"ce9675b808d0",[],[],{"_key":835,"_type":48,"children":836,"markDefs":841,"style":89},"e334225ba3e0",[837],{"_key":838,"_type":52,"marks":839,"text":840},"666f130ec1130",[],"Favorable perceptions (or lack thereof) follow the patterns we see with developers who are\u002Fplan on using or don’t plan on using AI tools.",[],{"_key":843,"_type":48,"children":844,"markDefs":849,"style":89},"a8cd180f817b",[845],{"_key":846,"_type":52,"marks":847,"text":848},"c54071bbac970",[],"Site reliability engineers and security professionals have the highest percentage of Unfavorable perceptions (6%) outside of game developers—likely because they see the potential risks they would have to deal with.",[],{"_key":851,"_type":48,"children":852,"markDefs":856,"style":89},"5209e5458c7e",[853],{"_key":854,"_type":52,"marks":855,"text":809},"cd3787ed1efa",[195],[],{"_key":858,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":859},"f9a51306b721",[860,862,867,872,877,882,887,892,896,900,905,909,913,917,921,925,928,931,936,941,945,949,953,956,961,965,968,973,977,981,984],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":861},[206,758,766,774],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":863},[292,864,865,866],"74.3%","22.3%","3.4%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":868},[300,869,870,871],"82.9%","15.4%","1.7%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":873},[308,874,875,876],"77.8%","18.7%","3.6%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":878},[316,879,880,881],"84.1%","14.5%","1.4%",{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":883},[324,884,885,886],"82.8%","14.9%","2.3%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":888},[331,889,890,891],"66.7%","33.3%","0.0%",{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":893},[339,359,894,895],"16.3%","5.4%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":897},[347,898,326,899],"76.2%","2.7%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":901},[355,902,903,904],"74.1%","24.1%","1.9%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":906},[363,907,472,908],"74.4%","5.7%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":910},[370,911,729,912],"71.4%","4.0%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":914},[377,915,393,916],"74.2%","3.3%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":918},[385,919,462,920],"71.1%","3.7%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":922},[392,923,456,924],"70.8%","3.1%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":926},[399,403,927,899],"19.4%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":929},[407,930,472,924],"77.0%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":932},[414,933,934,935],"70.6%","23.2%","6.2%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":937},[422,938,939,940],"74.7%","22.4%","2.9%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":942},[430,943,729,944],"71.5%","3.9%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":946},[438,947,948,886],"79.8%","17.9%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":950},[446,951,574,952],"69.7%","5.9%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":954},[453,930,955,916],"19.8%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":957},[461,958,959,960],"76.9%","19.3%","3.8%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":962},[469,568,963,964],"19.1%","2.2%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":966},[477,967,508,924],"76.4%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":969},[485,970,971,972],"75.5%","20.3%","4.3%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":974},[493,975,294,976],"75.9%","5.0%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":978},[499,975,979,980],"18.4%","5.8%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":982},[505,983,303,920],"79.6%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":985},[513,986,326,964],"76.6%",{"_key":988,"_type":48,"children":989,"markDefs":993,"style":172},"8023cd1003d6",[990],{"_key":991,"_type":52,"marks":992,"text":523},"8dceb1168a830",[],[],{"_key":995,"_type":48,"children":996,"markDefs":1001,"style":89},"73fe0e061f59",[997],{"_key":998,"_type":52,"marks":999,"text":1000},"1e4f56a171ae0",[],"Developers become more indifferent\u002Funsure about their perceptions of AI tools as part of their workflow as they increase in experience.",[],{"_key":1003,"_type":48,"children":1004,"markDefs":1008,"style":89},"eb63f5a3d8a5",[1005],{"_key":1006,"_type":52,"marks":1007,"text":809},"288c80901c770",[195],[],{"_key":1010,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1011},"25f4eff5a5c6",[1012,1014,1019,1023,1028,1032,1035],{"_key":815,"_type":204,"cells":1013},[206,758,766,774],{"_key":818,"_type":204,"cells":1015},[565,1016,1017,1018],"79.2%","17.8%","2.8%",{"_key":824,"_type":204,"cells":1020},[572,1021,1022,899],"78.4%","18.9%",{"_key":1024,"_type":204,"cells":1025},"ac27d51e-2e39-4294-be5a-46874e041774",[579,1026,1027,916],"75.4%","21.3%",{"_key":1029,"_type":204,"cells":1030},"232fd7d0-b9ff-4bcc-a21d-572bd171b00e",[586,1031,865,912],"73.6%",{"_key":1033,"_type":204,"cells":1034},"236d2732-719d-435b-99bb-75465f5c765a",[594,481,393,876],{"_key":1036,"_type":204,"cells":1037},"4355c25a-0c87-4b18-90cb-995219b807ac",[600,1038,1039,924],"73.1%","23.7%",{"_key":1041,"_type":48,"children":1042,"markDefs":1046,"style":172},"2ce55c2f1c68",[1043],{"_key":1044,"_type":52,"marks":1045,"text":658},"f01265e2afe50",[],[],{"_key":1048,"_type":48,"children":1049,"markDefs":1054,"style":89},"15cfe516369b",[1050],{"_key":1051,"_type":52,"marks":1052,"text":1053},"9775012b655a0",[],"Brazil has the largest number of professional developers who are favorable towards using AI tools in their development workflow. Poland and Germany have the highest percentages of developers who are indifferent or unsure (27% and 23%) and 1 out of 5 US professional developers are indifferent\u002Funsure.",[],{"_key":1056,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1057},"a92664853d30",[1058,1060,1064,1067,1069,1073,1077,1081,1085,1090,1094],{"_key":815,"_type":204,"cells":1059},[206,758,766,774],{"_key":818,"_type":204,"cells":1061},[682,1062,971,1063],"77.7%","2.0%",{"_key":824,"_type":204,"cells":1065},[687,1066,885,940],"82.2%",{"_key":1024,"_type":204,"cells":1068},[693,575,432,920],{"_key":1029,"_type":204,"cells":1070},[700,1071,1072,876],"79.3%","17.1%",{"_key":1033,"_type":204,"cells":1074},[707,1038,1075,1076],"23.3%","3.5%",{"_key":1036,"_type":204,"cells":1078},[714,1079,508,1080],"77.1%","2.4%",{"_key":1082,"_type":204,"cells":1083},"65197b32-8b7d-4bbc-a68c-75dcd790ca17",[722,930,1084,876],"19.5%",{"_key":1086,"_type":204,"cells":1087},"e423c19a-29d1-4b2a-9a1f-9ed0cb2d5186",[727,1088,441,1089],"68.0%","4.7%",{"_key":1091,"_type":204,"cells":1092},"d6410f3e-53fb-42d9-85c1-f5d7912dc444",[734,1088,1093,866],"20.9%",{"_key":1095,"_type":204,"cells":1096},"f06e376f-8568-4697-9bbc-c6379ad58667",[741,1031,939,960],{"_key":1098,"_type":48,"children":1099,"markDefs":1104,"style":56},"7ac3b752c511",[1100],{"_key":1101,"_type":52,"marks":1102,"text":1103},"b17228b105df",[],"Benefits of AI tools",[],{"_key":1106,"_type":48,"children":1107,"markDefs":1111,"style":172},"147fc310a0a5",[1108],{"_key":1109,"_type":52,"marks":1110,"text":170},"588491e9f9840",[],[],{"_key":1113,"_type":48,"children":1114,"markDefs":1119,"style":89},"1bccb838a3fa",[1115],{"_key":1116,"_type":52,"marks":1117,"text":1118},"a659d1d251e40",[],"For professional developers, they see the biggest benefit of using AI tools as part of their workflow as increasing productivity (37.4%), with secondary benefits of greater efficiency (27.9%) and speeding up learning (27.4%).",[],{"_key":1121,"_type":48,"children":1122,"markDefs":1127,"style":89},"ee5fb29ec835",[1123],{"_key":1124,"_type":52,"marks":1125,"text":1126},"634d23516e5a0",[],"For developers learning to code, they see the biggest benefits of using AI tools as part of their workflow as speeding up learning (42.4%) and increasing productivity (41.5%), with a secondary benefit of greater efficiency (33.7%).",[],{"_key":1129,"_type":48,"children":1130,"markDefs":1135,"style":89},"e1bed6eb063a",[1131],{"_key":1132,"_type":52,"marks":1133,"text":1134},"8d491c7ebde1",[],"Neither group expects AI tools to improve accuracy in coding—only 14.1% of professional developers and 23.8% of those learning to code see this as a benefit of AI tools.",[],{"_key":1137,"_type":48,"children":1138,"markDefs":1143,"style":259},"fb51a844f884",[1139],{"_key":1140,"_type":52,"marks":1141,"text":1142},"1917e1a2415d0",[],"Here is one of the biggest dichotomies of the expectations and perceptions of AI tools—developers see them as a way to increase their productivity and help them learn faster but they don’t expect accuracy from the output.",[],{"_key":1145,"_type":48,"children":1146,"markDefs":1151,"style":259},"c2fa60b37e87",[1147],{"_key":1148,"_type":52,"marks":1149,"text":1150},"3d096ab5727f0",[],"How can something you don’t necessarily trust to give you accurate outputs increase your productivity and speed of learning? We’ll explore more about this in the next section when we explore trust in the accuracy of the output.",[],{"_key":1153,"_type":48,"children":1154,"markDefs":1159,"style":89},"b8b0204638be",[1155],{"_key":1156,"_type":52,"marks":1157,"text":1158},"db206c50b2e3",[195],"For the AI tools you use as part of your development workflow, what are the MOST important benefits you are hoping to achieve?",[],{"_key":1161,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1162},"f8f7b6e48ec8",[1163,1171,1178],{"_key":1164,"_type":204,"cells":1165},"7c2022d4-2a4e-48bb-b9a4-c20c8c153e66",[206,1166,1167,1168,1169,1170],"Greater efficiency","Improve accuracy in coding","Improve collaboration","Increase productivity","Speed up learning",{"_key":1172,"_type":204,"cells":1173},"8d5ea4dc-eba2-41b9-a533-4e6df9d01b7d",[214,1174,1175,1176,1177,224],"27.9%","14.1%","4.2%","37.4%",{"_key":1179,"_type":204,"cells":1180},"b072ba44-91da-42f8-85a4-de048e8d5091",[222,295,735,1181,1182,1183],"6.8%","41.5%","42.4%",{"_key":1185,"_type":48,"children":1186,"markDefs":1190,"style":172},"57a6ed129d3b",[1187],{"_key":1188,"_type":52,"marks":1189,"text":233},"cc4dffccc049",[],[],{"_key":1192,"_type":48,"children":1193,"markDefs":1198,"style":89},"685dbaa4e2bf",[1194],{"_key":1195,"_type":52,"marks":1196,"text":1197},"b526f7b0d6c60",[],"When we look at the benefits that different developer types see in using AI tools, we see similar patterns as when we asked about usage and favorability.",[],{"_key":1200,"_type":48,"children":1201,"markDefs":1206,"style":89},"b8de15c13f8a",[1202],{"_key":1203,"_type":52,"marks":1204,"text":1205},"fc6851ed43c40",[],"Productivity is the biggest perceived benefit across all developer types.",[],{"_key":1208,"_type":48,"children":1209,"markDefs":1214,"style":89},"f773b36335a2",[1210],{"_key":1211,"_type":52,"marks":1212,"text":1213},"3dfc8e5ae2e30",[],"We see a split between greater efficiency and speeding up learning as the secondary benefit. The developer types who are a bit more skeptical\u002Funsure tend to see speeding up learning as more of a benefit than greater efficiency.",[],{"_key":1216,"_type":48,"children":1217,"markDefs":1221,"style":89},"1bcdce6d34f4",[1218],{"_key":1219,"_type":52,"marks":1220,"text":1158},"5ca697ff2ab80",[195],[],{"_key":1223,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1224},"ed0c68e80d90",[1225,1227,1232,1236,1242,1246,1251,1256,1260,1265,1269,1274,1279,1282,1286,1289,1293,1298,1304,1309,1313,1316,1320,1324,1328,1333,1337,1340,1344,1348,1353],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":1226},[206,1166,1167,1168,1169,1170],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":1228},[292,1229,1230,866,890,1231],"25.1%","12.3%","23.1%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":1233},[300,709,1234,960,1235,507],"11.5%","33.8%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":1237},[308,1238,1239,1240,1235,1241],"26.0%","11.7%","4.1%","22.1%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":1243},[316,494,1244,1245,424,743],"14.2%","5.2%",{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":1247},[324,1248,1230,960,1249,1250],"25.4%","32.1%","24.2%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":1252},[331,821,1253,1254,1255,649],"9.9%","5.6%","32.4%",{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":1257},[339,508,1258,866,1259,441],"17.0%","29.5%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":1261},[347,1229,1262,916,1263,1264],"10.7%","33.4%","25.2%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":1266},[355,1039,1267,952,1268,393],"13.0%","32.0%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":1270},[363,393,1271,1272,1273,1264],"12.0%","4.5%","32.7%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":1275},[370,508,1276,1277,643,1278],"14.7%","5.1%","27.8%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":1280},[377,1250,1239,866,1281,1264],"33.5%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":1283},[385,574,1284,866,1285,743],"12.1%","32.8%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":1287},[392,573,1288,826,333,379],"10.3%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":1290},[399,574,1291,944,1292,1075],"14.4%","31.8%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":1294},[407,1295,1296,876,1297,1039],"24.9%","12.7%","33.1%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":1299},[414,1300,1301,1302,1235,1303],"24.8%","10.5%","2.5%","25.3%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":1305},[422,709,1306,1307,1285,1308],"12.9%","5.5%","24.0%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":1310},[430,1311,1312,1080,333,1027],"29.9%","11.0%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":1314},[438,1308,1315,940,1263,1248],"12.2%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":1317},[446,1238,1318,964,1319,735],"10.8%","34.7%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":1321},[453,1248,1322,1076,1323,1231],"11.2%","35.0%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":1325},[461,1326,1181,899,1235,1327],"23.0%","28.4%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":1329},[469,1330,1331,1076,1332,1248],"20.4%","12.4%","34.8%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":1334},[477,1335,1336,1307,589,723],"22.8%","15.9%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":1338},[485,349,1339,924,1255,1229],"12.5%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":1341},[493,735,1234,1240,1342,1343],"34.4%","23%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":1345},[499,903,1346,822,1347,903],"11.4%","34.3%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":1349},[505,1350,1351,1352,1347,567],"25.5%","11.6%","4.8%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":1354},[513,695,1355,1089,890,393],"10.9%",{"_key":1357,"_type":48,"children":1358,"markDefs":1363,"style":89},"5199ee22b446",[1359],{"_key":1360,"_type":52,"marks":1361,"text":1362},"2c5ab36a59450",[],"\nNow let’s talk about the perception of improving accuracy (click the table header to sort) in coding being a benefit. Few developer types who are a bit more skeptical\u002Funsure see improving accuracy in coding as a benefit. Even the most positive and enthusiastic developer types—the data scientist\u002Fmachine learning specialists and data\u002Fbusiness analysts—have few who see accuracy improvements as a benefit.",[],{"_key":1365,"_type":48,"children":1366,"markDefs":1370,"style":172},"5dc8c74f650b",[1367],{"_key":1368,"_type":52,"marks":1369,"text":523},"c2db7031964e0",[],[],{"_key":1372,"_type":48,"children":1373,"markDefs":1378,"style":89},"b0d9fc9170ef",[1374],{"_key":1375,"_type":52,"marks":1376,"text":1377},"ccfc482c09f30",[],"We see minor variances between developers based on their years of experience.",[],{"_key":1380,"_type":48,"children":1381,"markDefs":1386,"style":89},"6817c31aa067",[1382],{"_key":1383,"_type":52,"marks":1384,"text":1385},"cc74f0f5582b0",[],"Interestingly, more developers in their mid to late career (11+ years) see increasing productivity as the biggest benefit, while developers early in their careers lean more towards speeding up learning and improving accuracy in coding.",[],{"_key":1388,"_type":48,"children":1389,"markDefs":1393,"style":89},"327ad5722352",[1390],{"_key":1391,"_type":52,"marks":1392,"text":1158},"fa232d8dc32d0",[195],[],{"_key":1395,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1396},"a355efd25729",[1397,1400,1406,1409,1413,1417,1422],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":1399},"f8c38500-0be0-45d6-b069-78be481dd8ae",[206,1166,1167,1168,1169,1170],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":1402},"3ccb4cda-1cef-4fdc-b4a4-0c794d0364ca",[565,1250,1403,1076,1404,1405],"13.1%","31.9%","25.8%",{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":1408},"4e53168a-2b91-4901-9af0-bb7c2d14cdf5",[572,1300,1267,912,1249,349],{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":1411},"4371baa7-602f-4d27-bc34-5618fb8a2c1f",[579,1295,1284,920,514,1412],"23.4%",{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":1415},"bc976c44-c318-41a5-b6da-7df20b737840",[586,1295,1416,826,1342,1412],"11.8%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":1419},"cda26091-41b7-486c-a964-8255f0433c58",[594,1075,1420,866,1421,574],"11.9%","34.1%",{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":1424},"a6ee6f86-43d2-487c-b2c2-2434fd2be6db",[600,1231,1296,1425,1421,729],"2.6%",{"_key":1427,"_type":48,"children":1428,"markDefs":1432,"style":172},"b443ee8f33c9",[1429],{"_key":1430,"_type":52,"marks":1431,"text":658},"65949f6ae27a0",[],[],{"_key":1434,"_type":48,"children":1435,"markDefs":1440,"style":89},"98528e023848",[1436],{"_key":1437,"_type":52,"marks":1438,"text":1439},"9d47f9a0b0800",[],"Increasing productivity continues to be the biggest benefit that professional developers see, regardless of their country. Brazil, India, and Poland developers see speeding up learning as the biggest secondary benefit, while the rest of the countries see the secondary benefit as being greater efficiency.",[],{"_key":1442,"_type":48,"children":1443,"markDefs":1448,"style":89},"7dc80ab54e0c",[1444],{"_key":1445,"_type":52,"marks":1446,"text":1447},"2a3912e67f6b0",[],"UK and Germany see the lowest percentage of developers who see improving accuracy in coding as a benefit.",[],{"_key":1450,"_type":48,"children":1451,"markDefs":1455,"style":89},"1b95ec7b73b8",[1452],{"_key":1453,"_type":52,"marks":1454,"text":1158},"0dd41c47caeb0",[195],[],{"_key":1457,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1458},"c0e2a36f5565",[1459,1461,1464,1468,1471,1475,1479,1483,1487,1492,1496],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":1460},[206,1166,1167,1168,1169,1170],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":1463},"756f3ba3-7fb9-4c26-80f2-d3728bec6719",[682,1405,1315,886,1263,903],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":1466},"df6b77fa-52bd-4431-954e-0dd42a9cba75",[687,416,1467,1352,1347,1303],"13.4%",{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":1470},"00cbcdd5-7730-4506-815f-d251198c7e44",[693,480,1420,916,479,1308],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":1473},"03c4274f-b598-45dd-8b0b-e6d977ce3858",[700,903,1474,1080,471,709],"12.8%",{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":1477},"7af40ea0-1b88-4171-ba08-da2bff815294",[707,425,1478,1302,295,650],"10.4%",{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":1481},"7d981dab-0f51-41d4-b617-bcedb6a47abe",[714,939,870,1482,357,735],"7.0%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":1485},"22f56ae5-52de-4fc5-acee-30dd19d6d694",[722,1405,1351,822,1486,1335],"34.2%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":1489},"0aeca493-69f9-457a-a794-a4a63960c6cb",[727,1075,1420,1490,1491,480],"2.1%","34.5%",{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":1494},"5e452fde-035f-4d48-bfc1-995a23296411",[734,1495,1301,1063,1332,1250],"26.4%",{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":1498},"e4c9e156-c202-4003-8d4a-6e71a639a853",[741,480,1420,822,479,650],{"_key":1500,"_type":48,"children":1501,"markDefs":1506,"style":56},"2c006e610020",[1502],{"_key":1503,"_type":52,"marks":1504,"text":1505},"712e592f6a090",[],"Trust in the accuracy of AI output",[],{"_key":1508,"_type":48,"children":1509,"markDefs":1514,"style":89},"80a008a6fca8",[1510],{"_key":1511,"_type":52,"marks":1512,"text":1513},"0fd07c5a8d3c0",[],"Across the board, regardless of how we slice the data, we see developers split on their trust in the accuracy of the AI output from tools.",[],{"_key":1516,"_type":48,"children":1517,"markDefs":1522,"style":89},"f5f9dbaeb52b",[1518],{"_key":1519,"_type":52,"marks":1520,"text":1521},"9e043550faf40",[],"Generally, professional developers, those with more experience, and those working on more complex challenges have less trust in the accuracy of the output.",[],{"_key":1524,"_type":48,"children":1525,"markDefs":1530,"style":89},"a34d551a82be",[1526],{"_key":1527,"_type":52,"marks":1528,"text":1529},"be17f84269c50",[],"This tells us that developers are thinking critically and\u002For skeptically about the output from AI tools rather than trusting it blindly. Taking a “trust but verify” or “don’t trust, verify” approach is the safest strategy with AI tools.",[],{"_key":1532,"_type":48,"children":1533,"markDefs":1537,"style":172},"dc51e9c96f1d",[1534],{"_key":1535,"_type":52,"marks":1536,"text":170},"598d88e016e20",[],[],{"_key":1539,"_type":48,"children":1540,"markDefs":1545,"style":89},"6c87a6bd0a60",[1541],{"_key":1542,"_type":52,"marks":1543,"text":1544},"04a7393e6d790",[],"Professional developers have a much lower level of trust in the accuracy of the output from AI tools (40%) than those who are learning to code (55%).",[],{"_key":1547,"_type":48,"children":1548,"markDefs":1553,"style":89},"031a989c3106",[1549],{"_key":1550,"_type":52,"marks":1551,"text":1552},"4684fca0bde50",[195],"How much do you trust the accuracy of the output from AI tools as part of your development workflow?",[],{"_key":1555,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1556},"0375bd82288e",[1557,1563,1568],{"_key":1558,"_type":204,"cells":1559},"b68d9684-e165-4495-badd-cdafefac4c77",[206,1560,1561,1562],"Trust","Neither trust nor distrust","Distrust",{"_key":1564,"_type":204,"cells":1565},"8ddfb367-88e2-4d26-820e-7a153e2e1960",[214,1566,1567,365],"40.2%","31.6%",{"_key":1569,"_type":204,"cells":1570},"627cfbff-6029-4f97-a694-ae854f20f01e",[222,566,695,225],{"_key":1572,"_type":48,"children":1573,"markDefs":1577,"style":172},"dd6efbed485d",[1574],{"_key":1575,"_type":52,"marks":1576,"text":233},"f87002e340580",[],[],{"_key":1579,"_type":48,"children":1580,"markDefs":1585,"style":89},"08f5f7dcc202",[1581],{"_key":1582,"_type":52,"marks":1583,"text":1584},"e36bb4f21bbd0",[],"While most developer types tend to trust of the accuracy of the AI output, there’s an almost equal number of those same developer types who don’t trust the accuracy of the output.",[],{"_key":1587,"_type":48,"children":1588,"markDefs":1592,"style":89},"76a651245f9c",[1589],{"_key":1590,"_type":52,"marks":1591,"text":1552},"b3712d23ff390",[195],[],{"_key":1594,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1595},"ede3de485685",[1596,1598,1602,1605,1607,1609,1612,1615,1619,1622,1624,1627,1630,1632,1635,1638,1642,1645,1648,1651,1654,1659,1663,1666,1668,1671,1674,1676,1679,1682,1686],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":1597},[206,1560,1561,1562],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":1599},[292,1600,1601,683],"37.3%","28.8%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":1603},[300,1604,332,1405],"45.9%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":1606},[308,1255,1263,1486],{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":1608},[316,400,216,709],{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":1610},[324,1611,1311,735],"46.3%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":1613},[331,1614,1248,695],"47.5%",{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":1616},[339,1617,216,1618],"51.8%","22.2%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":1620},[347,1621,589,333],"35.2%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":1623},[355,378,216,1347],{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":1625},[363,1626,433,1567],"38.6%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":1628},[370,1629,1332,1231],"42.0%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":1631},[377,716,1285,433],{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":1633},[385,1634,1281,433],"36.8%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":1636},[392,1637,1601,587],"31.7%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":1639},[399,1640,1641,723],"47.4%","31.2%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":1643},[407,708,1567,1644],"27.2%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":1646},[414,1332,441,1647],"37.9%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":1649},[422,317,1342,1650],"21.9%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":1652},[430,1653,880,348],"40.7%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":1655},[438,1656,1657,1658],"41.6%","28.5%","29.8%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":1660},[446,462,1661,1662],"36.7%","38.3%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":1664},[453,1665,1249,424],"37.7%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":1667},[461,1268,1259,702],{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":1669},[469,1670,1255,1644],"40.4%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":1672},[477,1673,333,1231],"44.6%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":1675},[485,1235,1281,1273],{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":1677},[493,1678,365,890],"38.4%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":1680},[499,433,1319,1681],"35.5%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":1683},[505,1684,333,1685],"37.1%","30.7%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":1687},[513,293,1495,1495],{"_key":1689,"_type":48,"children":1690,"markDefs":1694,"style":172},"bf916d474261",[1691],{"_key":1692,"_type":52,"marks":1693,"text":523},"510be79f9dc60",[],[],{"_key":1696,"_type":48,"children":1697,"markDefs":1702,"style":89},"dfb88eb9847d",[1698],{"_key":1699,"_type":52,"marks":1700,"text":1701},"f1c5329ca5460",[],"As developers go up in experience, they tend to be less trusting of the AI output from tools, with about a third of developers with more than 11 years of experience saying they distrust the output.",[],{"_key":1704,"_type":48,"children":1705,"markDefs":1709,"style":89},"57cb492c7d19",[1706],{"_key":1707,"_type":52,"marks":1708,"text":1552},"be0901b5b5340",[195],[],{"_key":1711,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1712},"96a7ef1b9dba",[1713,1715,1718,1721,1725,1727,1730],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":1714},[206,1560,1561,1562],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":1716},[565,1717,588,1248],"46.6%",{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":1719},[572,364,1720,318],"30.9%",{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":1722},[579,1723,1404,1724],"39.2%","28.9%",{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":1726},[586,488,333,1685],{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":1728},[594,1729,1491,1658],"35.7%",{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":1731},[600,595,1263,319],{"_key":1733,"_type":48,"children":1734,"markDefs":1739,"style":172},"c70efadcc5ef",[1735],{"_key":1736,"_type":52,"marks":1737,"text":1738},"e1b2aa9219ec0",[],"Professional developers by country",[],{"_key":1741,"_type":48,"children":1742,"markDefs":1747,"style":89},"c5b9f767514d",[1743],{"_key":1744,"_type":52,"marks":1745,"text":1746},"759e240169010",[],"Trust in the accuracy of AI output differs by country. Indian developers have the most trust in the output (55.2% trust it). Polish and German developers have the most distrust in the output (40% and 37.5% distrust it).",[],{"_key":1749,"_type":48,"children":1750,"markDefs":1755,"style":89},"25709719443e",[1751],{"_key":1752,"_type":52,"marks":1753,"text":1754},"5cf70f69d2690",[],"For developers in Australia, Canada, Germany, Netherlands, the UK, and the US, there are almost as many developers who don’t trust the output as there are that do trust the output.",[],{"_key":1757,"_type":48,"children":1758,"markDefs":1762,"style":89},"c959f1db9b73",[1759],{"_key":1760,"_type":52,"marks":1761,"text":1552},"df585436dd3e0",[195],[],{"_key":1764,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1765},"a1e75d31f3a0",[1766,1768,1771,1773,1775,1777,1779,1783,1786,1788,1790],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":1767},[206,1560,1561,1562],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":1769},[682,1678,1770,479],"29.0%",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":1772},[687,470,455,1308],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":1774},[693,447,1770,1263],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":1776},[700,500,1647,1238],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":1778},[707,643,1255,716],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":1780},[714,1781,1782,1420],"55.2%","32.9%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":1784},[722,1785,319,683],"35.4%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":1787},[727,487,890,701],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":1789},[734,1323,1567,1281],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":1791},[741,716,386,1792],"34.9%",{"_key":1794,"_type":48,"children":1795,"markDefs":1800,"style":56},"49aacd32af23",[1796],{"_key":1797,"_type":52,"marks":1798,"text":1799},"668f10d7dd54",[],"What parts of development workflow make sense for AI tools",[],{"_key":1802,"_type":48,"children":1803,"markDefs":1807,"style":172},"82b1c0064831",[1804],{"_key":1805,"_type":52,"marks":1806,"text":170},"0d07ba13041e0",[],[],{"_key":1809,"_type":48,"children":1810,"markDefs":1815,"style":89},"45dad112b391",[1811],{"_key":1812,"_type":52,"marks":1813,"text":1814},"184e7ad5f5e20",[],"Developers learning to code are more likely to be currently using AI tools to debug and get help (68%) and learn about a codebase (50%) than professional developers.",[],{"_key":1817,"_type":48,"children":1818,"markDefs":1823,"style":89},"778a6ad70c47",[1819],{"_key":1820,"_type":52,"marks":1821,"text":1822},"4185d801ecf10",[],"86% of professional developers are using AI tools to write code and 54% are using them to debug or get help, and they are looking forward to using AI tools in other parts of their workflow. Professional developers are most interested in using AI tools to test code (65%), commit and review code (64%), use them for deployment and monitoring (61%), and documenting code or learning about a codebase (58%).",[],{"_key":1825,"_type":48,"children":1826,"markDefs":1831,"style":89},"9c7969739587",[1827],{"_key":1828,"_type":52,"marks":1829,"text":1830},"8654eb94c514",[195],"Which parts of your development workflow are you currently using AI tools for and which are you interested in using AI tools for over the next year?",[],{"_key":1833,"_type":48,"children":1834,"markDefs":1839,"style":89},"7be7de8644b7",[1835],{"_key":1836,"_type":52,"marks":1837,"text":1838},"b1bebc323b440",[63],"Learning about a codebase",[],{"_key":1841,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1842},"1139d2fd6a61",[1843,1849,1854],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1845},"71a8a11f-9303-46f8-95c1-1a65345b2ea1",[206,1846,1847,1848],"Currently Using","Interested in Using","Not interested in Using",{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1851},"11405c33-9fd3-4c7c-b031-aac0d5ac3c78",[214,1285,1852,1853],"58.2%","15.2%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1856},"bf320d31-d697-4651-872b-114b5852e0bd",[222,1857,1858,1853],"50.0%","48.6%",{"_key":1860,"_type":48,"children":1861,"markDefs":1866,"style":89},"028f78f9840a",[1862],{"_key":1863,"_type":52,"marks":1864,"text":1865},"f8aca33e69890",[63],"Project planning",[],{"_key":1868,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1869},"fb9bc1453868",[1870,1872,1875],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1871},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1873},[214,1874,688,1723],"15.1%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1876},[222,1770,1877,216],"52.5%",{"_key":1879,"_type":48,"children":1880,"markDefs":1885,"style":89},"f10f24751ed7",[1881],{"_key":1882,"_type":52,"marks":1883,"text":1884},"718eaf5108260",[63],"Writing code",[],{"_key":1887,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1888},"fba77e24b072",[1889,1891,1895],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1890},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1892},[214,1893,349,1894],"86.2%","4.4%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1896},[222,1897,1278,935],"82.0%",{"_key":1899,"_type":48,"children":1900,"markDefs":1905,"style":89},"dc5ebabefbb2",[1901],{"_key":1902,"_type":52,"marks":1903,"text":1904},"aed6c80afe750",[63],"Documenting code",[],{"_key":1907,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1908},"bd9da75d832c",[1909,1911,1914],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1910},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1912},[214,701,1852,1913],"58.6%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1915},[222,1916,1917,1420],"38.2%","8.5%",{"_key":1919,"_type":48,"children":1920,"markDefs":1925,"style":89},"089b1adbba69",[1921],{"_key":1922,"_type":52,"marks":1923,"text":1924},"801babcab3550",[63],"Debugging and getting help",[],{"_key":1927,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1928},"0e9b3be8a930",[1929,1931,1935],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1930},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1932},[214,1933,1858,1934],"53.9%","7.5%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1936},[222,1933,1647,1937],"6.3%",{"_key":1939,"_type":48,"children":1940,"markDefs":1945,"style":89},"6f336c24ed5f",[1941],{"_key":1942,"_type":52,"marks":1943,"text":1944},"b1c5975900fb0",[63],"Testing code",[],{"_key":1947,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1948},"6c4d1a7177c9",[1949,1951,1954],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1950},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1952},[214,689,1953,1351],"65.2%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1955},[222,695,1956,1957],"62.1%","18.0%",{"_key":1959,"_type":48,"children":1960,"markDefs":1965,"style":89},"f55e4f5fff34",[1961],{"_key":1962,"_type":52,"marks":1963,"text":1964},"22e3cb73499e0",[63],"Committing and reviewing code",[],{"_key":1967,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1968},"c9eaee4691f5",[1969,1971,1976],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1970},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1972},[214,1973,1974,1975],"11.3%","63.7%","28.1%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1977},[222,1978,418,409],"22.9%",{"_key":1980,"_type":48,"children":1981,"markDefs":1986,"style":89},"ae3d659df87c",[1982],{"_key":1983,"_type":52,"marks":1984,"text":1985},"44d68535851a0",[63],"Deployment and monitoring",[],{"_key":1988,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":1989},"75091ba0cfb2",[1990,1992,1995],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":1991},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":1993},[214,952,1994,471],"61.0%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":1996},[222,1997,1998,478],"8.9%","53.7%",{"_key":2000,"_type":48,"children":2001,"markDefs":2006,"style":89},"cca213366615",[2002],{"_key":2003,"_type":52,"marks":2004,"text":2005},"b79e4a2cf6ad0",[63],"Collaborating with teammates",[],{"_key":2008,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2009},"5805ed3a8a88",[2010,2012,2015],{"_key":1844,"_type":204,"cells":2011},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1850,"_type":204,"cells":2013},[214,1089,1182,2014],"55.4%",{"_key":1855,"_type":204,"cells":2016},[222,2017,2018,2019],"7.3%","41.4%","54.7%",{"_key":2021,"_type":48,"children":2022,"markDefs":2026,"style":172},"32d8944a46ce",[2023],{"_key":2024,"_type":52,"marks":2025,"text":233},"a9c33e06f135",[],[],{"_key":2028,"_type":48,"children":2029,"markDefs":2034,"style":89},"d43a3103bc54",[2030],{"_key":2031,"_type":52,"marks":2032,"text":2033},"342649507df5",[],"This is a hefty section so we’ll hit the highlights for each table.",[],{"_key":2036,"_type":48,"children":2037,"markDefs":2041,"style":89},"760316fe20c9",[2038],{"_key":2039,"_type":52,"marks":2040,"text":1838},"3e04e79cb8cb0",[63],[],{"_key":2043,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2044},"50a210c632e0",[2045,2047,2049,2051,2054,2058,2061,2064,2068,2072,2075,2078,2081,2085,2087,2092,2095,2098,2101,2105,2107,2110,2114,2118,2120,2123,2125,2129,2132,2134,2137],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2046},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2048},[292,1647,1877,875],{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2050},[300,1640,1640,980],{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2052},[308,2053,2014,979],"31.3%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2055},[316,2056,2057,1288],"44.4%","49.6%",{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2059},[324,1285,2060,885],"59.2%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2062},[331,1857,2063,709],"45.5%",{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2065},[339,2066,348,2067],"48.3%","13.8%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2069},[347,890,2070,2071],"57.3%","15.3%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2073},[355,417,2074,2074],"50.9%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2076},[363,1916,2077,1416],"56.4%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2079},[370,1347,2080,1355],"62.0%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2082},[377,1685,2083,2084],"59.6%","15.7%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2086},[385,1297,223,1072],{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2088},[392,2089,2090,2091],"31.0%","58.8%","15.8%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2093},[399,1637,2094,1276],"60.0%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2096},[407,1782,2097,1874],"58.3%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2099},[414,415,2100,1239],"57.4%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2102},[422,1235,2103,2104],"57.5%","16.8%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2106},[430,409,1857,409],{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2108},[438,455,335,2109],"13.7%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2111},[446,2112,2113,1650],"28.6%","54.3%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2115},[453,1975,2116,2117],"64.4%","13.5%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2119},[461,1729,742,462],{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2121},[469,415,1857,2122],"17.2%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2124},[477,694,431,717],{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2126},[485,2127,2128,1230],"36.5%","56.6%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2130},[493,701,2131,1072],"51.4%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2133},[499,701,470,1075],{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2135},[505,217,737,2136],"13.2%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2138},[513,1611,1611,372],{"_key":2140,"_type":48,"children":2141,"markDefs":2145,"style":89},"58141e778462",[2142],{"_key":2143,"_type":52,"marks":2144,"text":1865},"804510be8c170",[63],[],{"_key":2147,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2148},"232307f5f95b",[2149,2151,2154,2158,2162,2164,2167,2169,2172,2175,2179,2183,2186,2189,2192,2194,2198,2201,2203,2206,2208,2212,2217,2219,2222,2225,2227,2230,2233,2237,2239],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2150},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2152},[292,1258,2153,580],"45.4%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2155},[300,2156,356,2157],"17.6%","35.3%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2159},[308,2160,2161,1673],"17.3%","40.8%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2163},[316,1303,394,456],{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2165},[324,303,2166,702],"46.7%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2168},[331,462,1857,1323],{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2170},[339,2112,2171,2112],"53.6%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2173},[347,2174,1566,464],"16.2%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2176},[355,1238,2177,2178],"34.0%","44.0%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2180},[363,2181,2182,1723],"17.5%","44.3%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2184},[370,743,2066,2185],"36.4%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2187},[377,1230,293,2188],"43.2%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2190},[385,1234,2191,423],"47.2%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2193},[392,1478,395,454],{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2195},[399,2117,2196,2197],"54.0%","35.6%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2199},[407,2200,431,702],"15.6%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2202},[414,1957,1611,587],{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2204},[422,880,1617,2205],"36.9%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2207},[430,2109,223,2157],{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2209},[438,2136,2210,2211],"48.7%","39.9%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2213},[446,2214,2215,2216],"10.2%","49.0%","42.9%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2218},[453,1853,1617,1491],{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2220},[461,1262,2216,2221],"46.4%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2223},[469,2224,1182,1182],"20.8%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2226},[477,432,1781,440],{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2228},[485,1258,2229,701],"46.2%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2231},[493,927,2232,1770],"51.6%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2234},[499,2235,2236,1998],"14.8%","31.5%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2238},[505,1258,465,1285],{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2240},[513,326,587,2241],"44.7%",{"_key":2243,"_type":48,"children":2244,"markDefs":2248,"style":89},"a1c046b2d84a",[2245],{"_key":2246,"_type":52,"marks":2247,"text":1884},"6528605dfe650",[63],[],{"_key":2250,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2251},"cfbc4163f3b1",[2252,2254,2257,2260,2264,2268,2271,2273,2277,2280,2283,2286,2289,2292,2295,2298,2301,2304,2308,2311,2313,2316,2318,2321,2324,2327,2329,2331,2333,2336,2340],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2253},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2255},[292,2256,934,980],"84.8%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2258},[300,2259,1303,1894],"85.4%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2261},[308,2262,2263,976],"85.3%","20.1%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2265},[316,2266,2089,2267],"84.9%","1.6%",{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2269},[324,2267,1495,2270],"4.6%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2272},[331,923,890,1176],{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2274},[339,2275,2185,2276],"72.7%","9.1%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2278},[347,2279,567,960],"88.2%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2281},[355,2282,379,1937],"82.5%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2284},[363,2285,402,952],"80.5%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2287},[370,2288,1273,912],"86.0%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2290},[377,2291,743,1352],"85.5%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2293},[385,2294,425,1176],"84.6%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2296},[392,2297,401,980],"80.9%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2299},[399,2300,462,920],"87.4%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2302},[407,2303,1412,1176],"87.5%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2305},[414,2306,409,2307],"81.1%","6.4%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2309},[422,2310,1174,1272],"85.1%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2312},[430,983,2236,920],{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2314},[438,2315,729,960],"84.4%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2317},[446,2291,1350,876],{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2319},[453,2320,494,916],"87.6%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2322},[461,2323,462,1339],"78.1%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2325},[469,2326,971,881],"87.0%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2328},[477,568,2177,2177],{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2330},[485,2291,379,972],{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2332},[493,879,709,1181],{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2334},[499,2335,1292,2276],"78.8%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2337},[505,2338,2339,826],"90.9%","21.0%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2341},[513,2342,463,1176],"89.6%",{"_key":2344,"_type":48,"children":2345,"markDefs":2349,"style":89},"602dd227fdd6",[2346],{"_key":2347,"_type":52,"marks":2348,"text":1904},"a1447a7e409e0",[63],[],{"_key":2351,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2352},"65ad9e73f299",[2353,2355,2359,2363,2366,2369,2372,2376,2380,2382,2387,2391,2395,2398,2401,2406,2408,2412,2415,2419,2422,2425,2428,2431,2434,2437,2440,2444,2447,2450,2453],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2354},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2356},[292,454,2357,2358],"56.9%","7.9%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2360},[300,2361,348,2362],"54.5%","8.4%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2364},[308,2018,418,2365],"7.8%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2367},[316,708,2083,2368],"6.1%",{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2370},[324,715,2371,1307],"55.5%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2373},[331,2374,2216,2375],"57.1%","14.3%",{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2377},[339,1653,2378,2379],"63.0%","7.4%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2381},[347,694,1852,1934],{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2383},[355,2384,2385,2386],"55.7%","50.8%","4.9%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2388},[363,2389,2390,2214],"41.7%","54.6%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2392},[370,1653,2393,2394],"54.8%","12.6%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2396},[377,2397,1852,1253],"38.9%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2399},[385,1601,2400,1346],"64.0%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2402},[392,2403,2404,2405],"38.0%","58.1%","9.3%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2407},[399,488,489,1181],{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2409},[407,1566,2410,2411],"57.7%","8.6%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2413},[414,1641,2414,1331],"61.5%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2416},[422,2417,2418,1482],"37.8%","62.2%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2420},[430,1273,2421,1234],"63.5%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2423},[438,2221,2424,876],"57.0%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2426},[446,2215,2427,1234],"47.1%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2429},[453,1653,2430,980],"59.5%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2432},[461,1647,2433,432],"51.7%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2435},[469,317,2436,1937],"56.3%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2438},[477,2216,2232,2439],"8.8%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2441},[485,2442,2443,1937],"40.9%","59.1%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2445},[493,2446,2077,1288],"41.0%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2448},[499,1600,2385,2449],"16.9%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2451},[505,356,2452,952],"53.1%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2454},[513,2455,2404,2456],"41.9%","14.0%",{"_key":2458,"_type":48,"children":2459,"markDefs":2463,"style":89},"402fa486dcbe",[2460],{"_key":2461,"_type":52,"marks":2462,"text":1924},"caaae939286f0",[63],[],{"_key":2465,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2466},"ad432ce95ee7",[2467,2469,2472,2475,2478,2480,2482,2484,2488,2492,2495,2498,2502,2504,2506,2511,2514,2517,2521,2524,2526,2530,2534,2537,2539,2541,2544,2548,2551,2553,2556],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2468},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2470},[292,2131,2471,1416],"45.3%",{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2473},[300,2474,417,976],"57.6%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2476},[308,2477,2178,1262],"52.8%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2479},[316,301,1566,2362],{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2481},[324,2390,2066,2368],{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2483},[331,2216,408,294],{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2485},[339,2486,2221,2487],"64.3%","7.1%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2489},[347,2094,2490,2491],"42.7%","6.9%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2493},[355,2494,2100,1254],"48.1%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2496},[363,2191,2497,2214],"49.1%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2499},[370,2500,580,2501],"65.0%","6.6%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2503},[377,2210,1877,2362],{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2505},[385,2182,2171,1253],{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2507},[392,2508,2509,2510],"49.2%","49.7%","9.6%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2512},[399,2513,2427,1245],"59.7%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2515},[407,2516,356,1181],"55.3%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2518},[414,2519,2520,1997],"49.8%","49.3%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2522},[422,2523,2519,2017],"54.1%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2525},[430,2083,580,1234],{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2527},[438,2528,2529,980],"53.3%","50.6%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2531},[446,2070,2532,2533],"43.7%","9.7%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2535},[453,408,2477,2536],"8.0%",{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2538},[461,2232,395,2533],{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2540},[469,2384,2508,2501],{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2542},[477,2543,378,2214],"56.8%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2545},[485,2546,2547,2368],"50.3%","53.4%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2549},[493,2550,400,1277],"53.8%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2552},[499,465,1600,2449],{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2554},[505,2555,2385,2501],"49.4%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2557},[513,2558,2559,972],"56.5%","58.7%",{"_key":2561,"_type":48,"children":2562,"markDefs":2566,"style":89},"5ce30b107b15",[2563],{"_key":2564,"_type":52,"marks":2565,"text":1944},"33918352afad0",[63],[],{"_key":2568,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2569},"ef26f80bcbe7",[2570,2572,2574,2576,2579,2581,2583,2585,2589,2592,2595,2598,2601,2603,2606,2608,2610,2613,2617,2620,2623,2626,2629,2631,2633,2636,2638,2641,2644,2647,2650],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2571},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2573},[292,1231,296,2104],{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2575},[300,350,1974,2510],{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2577},[308,401,2578,1239],"65.1%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2580},[316,1273,2410,2117],{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2582},[324,1229,381,1284],{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2584},[331,701,1857,462],{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2586},[339,488,2587,2588],"59.3%","11.1%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2590},[347,1405,2591,1318],"69.5%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2593},[355,1626,2594,1076],"64.9%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2596},[363,462,2597,2588],"68.5%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2599},[370,311,1913,2600],"15.0%",{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2602},[377,319,596,1416],{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2604},[385,1022,2605,1315],"72.4%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2607},[392,1335,590,2235],{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2609},[399,1486,2500,2411],{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2611},[407,1259,2612,1312],"65.3%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2614},[414,2615,2616,2067],"21.6%","67.4%",{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2618},[422,440,2619,1288],"68.4%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2621},[430,1350,2622,2084],"62.7%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2624},[438,1495,2625,1239],"66.6%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2627},[446,2628,1994,1072],"25.7%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2630},[453,1249,590,2491],{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2632},[461,567,2221,1729],{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2634},[469,456,457,2635],"5.3%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2637},[477,326,696,1315],{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2639},[485,574,2640,1262],"69.1%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2642},[493,1567,2643,1301],"63.2%",{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2645},[499,358,2646,358],"63.3%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2648},[505,1782,684,2649],"6.5%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2651},[513,349,889,2652],"20.0%",{"_key":2654,"_type":48,"children":2655,"markDefs":2659,"style":89},"46ca71782685",[2656],{"_key":2657,"_type":52,"marks":2658,"text":1964},"2f49d43f36d50",[63],[],{"_key":2661,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2662},"4eaf0b102703",[2663,2665,2667,2671,2674,2676,2679,2681,2683,2685,2688,2690,2692,2695,2699,2702,2704,2707,2709,2712,2715,2717,2719,2721,2724,2727,2730,2733,2735,2737,2739],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2664},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2666},[292,1917,684,581],{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2668},[300,2669,2670,318],"9.8%","66.9%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2672},[308,1474,2673,440],"60.8%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2675},[316,1957,2378,1326],{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2677},[324,1301,2678,318],"66.4%",{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2680},[331,2652,470,470],{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2682},[339,1339,923,2224],{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2684},[347,1267,501,1644],{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2686},[355,2588,2687,903],"72.2%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2689},[363,2071,2418,574],{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2691},[370,1351,325,683],{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2693},[377,1355,2694,689],"62.9%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2696},[385,2697,2698,1259],"8.2%","64.8%",{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2700},[392,2701,2418,1404],"8.1%",{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2703},[399,1271,2670,462],{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2705},[407,1234,2706,1174],"63.6%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2708},[414,1267,2421,372],{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2710},[422,1239,2711,425],"65.4%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2713},[430,1176,2714,1785],"60.4%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2716},[438,2701,2698,463],{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2718},[446,2701,2706,424],{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2720},[453,1288,351,1412],{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2722},[461,920,2723,1653],"55.6%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2725},[469,1296,2275,2726],"18.2%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2728},[477,1336,2729,1621],"52.3%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2731},[485,1346,2732,401],"65.5%",{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2734},[493,1318,730,2615],{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2736},[499,1254,1998,2056],{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2738},[505,1318,864,948],{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2740},[513,393,2741,701],"42.5%",{"_key":2743,"_type":48,"children":2744,"markDefs":2748,"style":89},"f4870922fc9f",[2745],{"_key":2746,"_type":52,"marks":2747,"text":1985},"09d8048232c10",[63],[],{"_key":2750,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2751},"4d3471ff965f",[2752,2754,2756,2759,2762,2764,2766,2768,2771,2775,2778,2780,2782,2785,2787,2789,2792,2795,2797,2799,2803,2806,2809,2811,2814,2817,2819,2821,2823,2826,2828],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2753},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2755},[292,1937,2378,1785],{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2757},[300,1312,566,2758],"34.6%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2760},[308,2501,2761,683],"61.8%",{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2763},[316,1284,301,1495],{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2765},[324,2368,737,1491],{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2767},[331,2600,470,1857],{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2769},[339,1271,2770,701],"56.0%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2772},[347,2773,2774,1637],"10.6%","59.8%",{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2776},[355,1240,2777,2112],"67.3%",{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2779},[363,1301,2232,2397],{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2781},[370,1917,2070,2455],{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2783},[377,976,335,2784],"36.2%",{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2786},[385,920,2770,2018],{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2788},[392,1089,2546,648],{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2790},[399,2635,2791,1347],"62.3%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2793},[407,2794,1956,1235],"6.0%",{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2796},[414,908,1933,2741],{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2798},[422,1245,301,1486],{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2800},[430,1063,2801,2802],"52.0%","46.0%",{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2804},[438,960,2805,1792],"63.8%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2807},[446,2368,2808,1319],"61.2%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2810},[453,935,351,441],{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2812},[461,891,2801,2813],"48.0%",{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2815},[469,908,2816,332],"67.9%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2818},[477,2487,2094,2157],{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2820},[485,1254,2559,1600],{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2822},[493,952,2761,1255],{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2824},[499,895,2825,1617],"48.2%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2827},[505,1917,923,573],{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2829},[513,948,2229,2446],{"_key":2831,"_type":48,"children":2832,"markDefs":2836,"style":89},"61669a052b0b",[2833],{"_key":2834,"_type":52,"marks":2835,"text":2005},"b79dfa1d6cbd0",[63],[],{"_key":2838,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2839},"796407b597c4",[2840,2842,2844,2847,2849,2852,2854,2857,2860,2862,2864,2867,2869,2871,2873,2875,2878,2880,2882,2885,2887,2890,2893,2895,2897,2901,2904,2906,2908,2911,2914],{"_key":287,"_type":204,"cells":2841},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":290,"_type":204,"cells":2843},[292,2487,1670,2436],{"_key":298,"_type":204,"cells":2845},[300,1352,2846,2393],"42.1%",{"_key":306,"_type":204,"cells":2848},[308,2386,2211,2357],{"_key":314,"_type":204,"cells":2850},[316,2375,293,2851],"39.6%",{"_key":322,"_type":204,"cells":2853},[324,1307,348,400],{"_key":329,"_type":204,"cells":2855},[331,2856,2856,2094],"10.0%",{"_key":337,"_type":204,"cells":2858},[339,2859,595,2801],"16.0%",{"_key":345,"_type":204,"cells":2861},[347,1272,701,2103],{"_key":353,"_type":204,"cells":2863},[355,2649,1332,2559],{"_key":361,"_type":204,"cells":2865},[363,2501,309,2866],"50.5%",{"_key":368,"_type":204,"cells":2868},[370,908,2446,2404],{"_key":375,"_type":204,"cells":2870},[377,1176,334,2474],{"_key":383,"_type":204,"cells":2872},[385,876,488,449],{"_key":390,"_type":204,"cells":2874},[392,916,1678,2060],{"_key":397,"_type":204,"cells":2876},[399,895,417,2877],"52.6%",{"_key":405,"_type":204,"cells":2879},[407,1176,602,566],{"_key":412,"_type":204,"cells":2881},[414,2487,1626,2770],{"_key":420,"_type":204,"cells":2883},[422,2386,387,2884],"52.7%",{"_key":428,"_type":204,"cells":2886},[430,2368,1319,2060],{"_key":436,"_type":204,"cells":2888},[438,980,387,2889],"51.1%",{"_key":444,"_type":204,"cells":2891},[446,826,2892,388],"41.1%",{"_key":451,"_type":204,"cells":2894},[453,2270,2191,2508],{"_key":459,"_type":204,"cells":2896},[461,1234,702,2550],{"_key":467,"_type":204,"cells":2898},[469,2214,2899,2900],"46.9%","44.9%",{"_key":475,"_type":204,"cells":2902},[477,2903,2216,1857],"8.3%",{"_key":483,"_type":204,"cells":2905},[485,1307,454,2528],{"_key":491,"_type":204,"cells":2907},[493,2856,2166,342],{"_key":497,"_type":204,"cells":2909},[499,1063,2910,933],"29.4%",{"_key":503,"_type":204,"cells":2912},[505,2368,2913,1673],"51.2%",{"_key":511,"_type":204,"cells":2915},[513,2916,1421,418],"14.6%",{"_key":2918,"_type":48,"children":2919,"markDefs":2923,"style":172},"6b48de4d6512",[2920],{"_key":2921,"_type":52,"marks":2922,"text":523},"1e641df9a7c7",[],[],{"_key":2925,"_type":48,"children":2926,"markDefs":2931,"style":89},"1483b1a3e82b",[2927],{"_key":2928,"_type":52,"marks":2929,"text":2930},"7a24dbbae103",[],"Use of AI tools now and interest in using them in the future is mainly consistent across the years of experience. However, developers in earlier in their careers (\u003C=10 years) are using AI tools for debugging and to get help now, more than developers with 11+ years of experience.",[],{"_key":2933,"_type":48,"children":2934,"markDefs":2938,"style":89},"2613eea21c4c",[2935],{"_key":2936,"_type":52,"marks":2937,"text":1838},"7b799d75fd050",[63],[],{"_key":2940,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2941},"2c30ac4bc8fc",[2942,2944,2946,2948,2951,2955,2957],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":2943},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":2945},[565,1491,1913,885],{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":2947},[572,2177,2097,885],{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":2949},[579,332,2950,2200],"61.9%",{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":2952},[586,1278,2953,2954],"61.7%","15.5%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":2956},[594,433,2791,2375],{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":2958},[600,683,2959,2136],"60.1%",{"_key":2961,"_type":48,"children":2962,"markDefs":2966,"style":89},"45db32d9d209",[2963],{"_key":2964,"_type":52,"marks":2965,"text":1865},"03df56be3ab30",[63],[],{"_key":2968,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2969},"6ff0444b0092",[2970,2972,2974,2976,2978,2982,2985],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":2971},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":2973},[565,225,2529,1661],{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":2975},[572,1072,2433,2157],{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":2977},[579,2067,2385,1678],{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":2979},[586,1420,2980,2981],"50.1%","40.5%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":2983},[594,2394,2191,2984],"43.0%",{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":2986},[600,1271,715,348],{"_key":2988,"_type":48,"children":2989,"markDefs":2993,"style":89},"8d79e6ac53a2",[2990],{"_key":2991,"_type":52,"marks":2992,"text":1884},"f2955a3440eb0",[63],[],{"_key":2995,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":2996},"04aaa00a5949",[2997,2999,3002,3004,3007,3010,3013],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":2998},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":3000},[565,3001,507,1277],"83.7%",{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":3003},[572,2288,1303,1245],{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":3005},[579,3006,1350,1176],"86.3%",{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":3008},[586,3009,2628,912],"85.6%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":3011},[594,3012,1978,944],"87.1%",{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":3014},[600,3015,650,944],"88.1%",{"_key":3017,"_type":48,"children":3018,"markDefs":3022,"style":89},"4de5d81eb192",[3019],{"_key":3020,"_type":52,"marks":3021,"text":1904},"50901d9e6a8b0",[63],[],{"_key":3024,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3025},"398d0ef5c9e5",[3026,3028,3031,3035,3037,3039,3042],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3027},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":3029},[565,3030,2643,2536],"39.1%",{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":3032},[572,3033,3034,2536],"40.6%","59.0%",{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":3036},[579,1670,2559,2358],{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":3038},[586,2851,2090,2903],{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":3040},[594,378,3041,2358],"58.5%",{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":3043},[600,2197,1994,2510],{"_key":3045,"_type":48,"children":3046,"markDefs":3050,"style":89},"1240dd759fba",[3047],{"_key":3048,"_type":52,"marks":3049,"text":1924},"e79e0081d18c0",[63],[],{"_key":3052,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3053},"d533c6ccbf56",[3054,3056,3058,3060,3062,3065,3067],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3055},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":3057},[565,442,2403,916],{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":3059},[572,2673,2471,1937],{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":3061},[579,394,2131,2017],{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":3063},[586,648,2171,3064],"9.2%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":3066},[594,439,418,2358],{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":3068},[600,464,2371,2365],{"_key":3070,"_type":48,"children":3071,"markDefs":3075,"style":89},"61fbdfd01f73",[3072],{"_key":3073,"_type":52,"marks":3074,"text":1944},"a7199ede88200",[63],[],{"_key":3077,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3078},"c97850fc1319",[3079,3081,3085,3089,3092,3095,3098],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3080},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":3082},[565,2910,3083,3084],"68.2%","9.4%",{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":3086},[572,1658,3087,3088],"63.4%","13.3%",{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":3090},[579,350,3091,2214],"65.6%",{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":3093},[586,357,3094,2701],"67.7%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":3096},[594,1644,3097,2439],"69.0%",{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":3099},[600,601,3100,3101],"69.3%","9.0%",{"_key":3103,"_type":48,"children":3104,"markDefs":3108,"style":89},"47893e7ca912",[3105],{"_key":3106,"_type":52,"marks":3107,"text":1964},"6fe9befc79d80",[63],[],{"_key":3110,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3111},"b524d5a4afd5",[3112,3114,3116,3119,3122,3125,3128],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3113},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":3115},[565,3101,3034,890],{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":3117},[572,2394,3118,424],"60.9%",{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":3120},[579,2588,3121,425],"65.8%",{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":3123},[586,3124,590,462],"10.1%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":3126},[594,1997,3127,1978],"70.4%",{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":3129},[600,1351,434,2615],{"_key":3131,"_type":48,"children":3132,"markDefs":3136,"style":89},"6a5d1d5c1a9c",[3133],{"_key":3134,"_type":52,"marks":3135,"text":1985},"1d7fbc5b98bc0",[63],[],{"_key":3138,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3139},"de814d3bde32",[3140,3142,3144,3147,3150,3152,3154],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3141},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":3143},[565,899,2019,2178],{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":3145},[572,1181,3146,2127],"58.9%",{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":3148},[579,3149,2418,1486],"6%",{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":3151},[586,2386,684,350],{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":3153},[594,895,889,2910],{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":3155},[600,1277,3097,1327],{"_key":3157,"_type":48,"children":3158,"markDefs":3162,"style":89},"83ca214bfaa4",[3159],{"_key":3160,"_type":52,"marks":3161,"text":2005},"c725e859968f0",[63],[],{"_key":3164,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3165},"b9e38e01dea9",[3166,3168,3171,3173,3175,3178,3180],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3167},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1401,"_type":204,"cells":3169},[565,881,1235,3170],"66.2%",{"_key":1407,"_type":204,"cells":3172},[572,1307,2389,2393],{"_key":1410,"_type":204,"cells":3174},[579,2635,454,2550],{"_key":1414,"_type":204,"cells":3176},[586,1176,2471,3177],"52.1%",{"_key":1418,"_type":204,"cells":3179},[594,3177,2471,2232],{"_key":1423,"_type":204,"cells":3181},[600,1277,3182,3183],"44.5%","52.4%",{"_key":3185,"_type":48,"children":3186,"markDefs":3190,"style":172},"ac94494ae2cb",[3187],{"_key":3188,"_type":52,"marks":3189,"text":1738},"46cd58ce898c",[],[],{"_key":3192,"_type":48,"children":3193,"markDefs":3198,"style":89},"0379bddec371",[3194],{"_key":3195,"_type":52,"marks":3196,"text":3197},"06a598b5ee990",[],"Use of AI tools now and interest in using them in the future is mainly consistent across countries.",[],{"_key":3200,"_type":48,"children":3201,"markDefs":3206,"style":89},"fe52788c2963",[3202],{"_key":3203,"_type":52,"marks":3204,"text":3205},"757b472a31b30",[],"Germany and Poland developers aren’t currently using AI tools as much to debug and get help but they are interested in using them in the future.",[],{"_key":3208,"_type":48,"children":3209,"markDefs":3214,"style":89},"ecdbef57fa1c",[3210],{"_key":3211,"_type":52,"marks":3212,"text":3213},"29a8f74e662f0",[],"India developers are more interested in using AI tools to collaborate with teammates (54%) - the highest percentage by far across the countries.",[],{"_key":3216,"_type":48,"children":3217,"markDefs":3221,"style":89},"6b715c88b360",[3218],{"_key":3219,"_type":52,"marks":3220,"text":1838},"78b982635386",[63],[],{"_key":3223,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3224},"ca087ce1c568",[3225,3227,3230,3232,3234,3236,3238,3240,3242,3244,3246],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3226},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3228},[682,3229,2090,2071],"30.5%",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3231},[687,2417,1857,2156],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3233},[693,3229,2094,1403],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3235},[700,1657,2014,2014],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3237},[707,1405,2418,2091],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3239},[714,1673,2474,2510],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3241},[722,425,2436,1093],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3243},[727,649,2558,1330],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3245},[734,487,2959,2104],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3247},[741,372,703,1291],{"_key":3249,"_type":48,"children":3250,"markDefs":3254,"style":89},"44c9d379dab7",[3251],{"_key":3252,"_type":52,"marks":3253,"text":1865},"189a993a3df90",[63],[],{"_key":3256,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3257},"19a8c9122131",[3258,3260,3263,3265,3267,3269,3271,3274,3277,3280,3282],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3259},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3261},[682,1284,3262,2532],"47.0%",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3264},[687,303,2229,334],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3266},[693,3088,1617,1684],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3268},[700,2017,1656,2801],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3270},[707,1322,387,2221],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3272},[714,448,3273,939],"62.8%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3275},[722,2405,1723,3276],"53.0%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3278},[727,2856,348,3279],"47.7%",{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3281},[734,1262,2221,1673],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3283},[741,2174,2066,1662],{"_key":3285,"_type":48,"children":3286,"markDefs":3290,"style":89},"63102b4845f3",[3287],{"_key":3288,"_type":52,"marks":3289,"text":1884},"f48d756f8f650",[63],[],{"_key":3292,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3293},"72eb7b5d9b0f",[3294,3296,3299,3301,3303,3305,3309,3311,3314,3317,3319],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3295},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3297},[682,3298,2726,2726],"90.1%",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3300},[687,2288,2339,1089],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3302},[693,2300,508,972],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3304},[700,3009,2263,1352],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3306},[707,3307,3308,972],"86.8%","21.8%",{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3310},[714,3001,514,1277],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3312},[722,3313,3308,944],"86.9%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3315},[727,3316,365,972],"85.7%",{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3318},[734,2303,979,1894],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3320},[741,3307,1326,944],{"_key":3322,"_type":48,"children":3323,"markDefs":3327,"style":89},"b1dabc1560b1",[3324],{"_key":3325,"_type":52,"marks":3326,"text":1904},"d392077f69050",[63],[],{"_key":3329,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3330},"5921d4d00014",[3331,3333,3335,3337,3340,3342,3344,3347,3349,3352,3355],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3332},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3334},[682,2892,2516,2701],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3336},[687,1600,2558,1318],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3338},[693,334,3339,1917],"57.2%",{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3341},[700,2490,2477,3064],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3343},[707,1629,1933,3064],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3345},[714,3346,2761,908],"45.2%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3348},[722,694,1781,2405],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3350},[727,447,3351,1239],"58.4%",{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3353},[734,488,3041,3354],"8.7%",{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3356},[741,1647,2774,2701],{"_key":3358,"_type":48,"children":3359,"markDefs":3363,"style":89},"a74c0a817593",[3360],{"_key":3361,"_type":52,"marks":3362,"text":1924},"7255575868a70",[63],[],{"_key":3365,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3366},"202c1d9766c9",[3367,3369,3371,3373,3376,3381,3383,3385,3387,3389,3391],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3368},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3370},[682,2232,395,2491],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3372},[687,2171,2056,3124],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3374},[693,3375,2057,2365],"51.9%",{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3377},[700,3378,3379,3380],"53.5%","45.7%","7.7%",{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3382},[707,431,2509,2362],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3384},[714,325,2433,2635],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3386},[722,2889,356,2362],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3388},[727,2899,465,3101],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3390},[734,2385,2210,2365],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3392},[741,2361,3279,3393],"6.7%",{"_key":3395,"_type":48,"children":3396,"markDefs":3400,"style":89},"54ee78b6b33b",[3397],{"_key":3398,"_type":52,"marks":3399,"text":1944},"f1777e52d9000",[63],[],{"_key":3402,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3403},"a72d892548b5",[3404,3406,3408,3410,3413,3415,3418,3420,3422,3424,3426],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3405},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3407},[682,357,501,1239],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3409},[687,1665,2070,2773],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3411},[693,1657,3412,3064],"67.0%",{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3414},[700,401,2761,870],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3416},[707,2628,3091,3417],"13.6%",{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3419},[714,463,312,1351],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3421},[722,1249,703,1306],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3423},[727,1685,2808,2109],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3425},[734,365,1974,1230],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3427},[741,695,3428,1301],"67.6%",{"_key":3430,"_type":48,"children":3431,"markDefs":3435,"style":89},"ef1f1b3b6289",[3432],{"_key":3433,"_type":52,"marks":3434,"text":1964},"8e7405837a3b0",[63],[],{"_key":3437,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3438},"1032d61331a3",[3439,3441,3443,3445,3447,3449,3451,3453,3455,3457,3459],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3440},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3442},[682,2536,2706,217],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3444},[687,1351,1974,441],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3446},[693,3084,2594,365],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3448},[700,2701,3273,350],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3450},[707,1934,596,424],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3452},[714,821,2116,1978],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3454},[722,2405,2643,2089],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3456},[727,1253,3118,333],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3458},[734,2358,2622,2236],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3460},[741,2903,3461,372],"64.7%",{"_key":3463,"_type":48,"children":3464,"markDefs":3468,"style":89},"34d8f7bff4f9",[3465],{"_key":3466,"_type":52,"marks":3467,"text":1985},"fd6cd594b63a0",[63],[],{"_key":3470,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3471},"b3df4130159d",[3472,3474,3476,3478,3480,3482,3484,3486,3488,3490,3492],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3473},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3475},[682,2270,2622,295],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3477},[687,2649,3034,486],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3479},[693,2270,2116,333],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3481},[700,876,2100,3033],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3483},[707,1240,2357,1566],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3485},[714,2136,3091,3091],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3487},[722,944,3041,1670],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3489},[727,2386,2074,1604],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3491},[734,944,2094,2417],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3493},[741,912,2732,1404],{"_key":3495,"_type":48,"children":3496,"markDefs":3500,"style":89},"e1b5b9d25404",[3497],{"_key":3498,"_type":52,"marks":3499,"text":2005},"c7f23ae938ab0",[63],[],{"_key":3502,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3503},"8715fa95f6a8",[3504,3506,3508,3510,3512,3514,3516,3518,3520,3522,3524],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3505},[206,1846,1847,1848],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3507},[682,876,417,2196],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3509},[687,1937,2389,506],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3511},[693,920,3033,2424],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3513},[700,881,447,2080],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3515},[707,1076,1342,2643],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3517},[714,1351,2196,1723],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3519},[722,916,683,2805],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3521},[727,940,643,3083],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3523},[734,886,378,3041],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3525},[741,1076,439,2171],{"_key":3527,"_type":48,"children":3528,"markDefs":3532,"style":89},"28617118c0fb",[3529],{"_key":3530,"_type":52,"marks":3531,"text":206},"a540f4a3551e0",[],[],{"_key":3534,"_type":48,"children":3535,"markDefs":3540,"style":56},"96dca37ff28c",[3536],{"_key":3537,"_type":52,"marks":3538,"text":3539},"bca27befb51e0",[],"How similar or different do you see your workflow in 1 year as a result of using AI tools?",[],{"_key":3542,"_type":48,"children":3543,"markDefs":3547,"style":172},"56580603c17c",[3544],{"_key":3545,"_type":52,"marks":3546,"text":170},"78a6407996630",[],[],{"_key":3549,"_type":48,"children":3550,"markDefs":3555,"style":89},"08c16041e691",[3551],{"_key":3552,"_type":52,"marks":3553,"text":3554},"df7540cf23df0",[],"Regardless of being a professional developer or someone learning to code, people believe that their development workflow will be different in a year because of AI tools.",[],{"_key":3557,"_type":48,"children":3558,"markDefs":3563,"style":89},"13b633af8abe",[3559],{"_key":3560,"_type":52,"marks":3561,"text":3562},"732ef35d792a0",[195],"Thinking about how your workflow and process changes over time, how similar or different do you anticipate your workflow to be 1 year from now as a result of AI tools you are currently using?",[],{"_key":3565,"_type":48,"children":3566,"markDefs":3570,"style":89},"24aa6e0571a9",[3567],{"_key":3568,"_type":52,"marks":3569,"text":1838},"cd3211cbe2760",[63],[],{"_key":3572,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3573},"6992587f35d2",[3574,3580,3584],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3576},"48a343e7-0efb-48c3-9166-ed4c4376b2d9",[206,3577,3578,3579],"Different","Neither different nor similiar","Similar",{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3582},"9dc4cfd1-bc14-43cd-b155-bdaad95f5c06",[214,3583,2856,1267],"78.5%",{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3586},"eff2e719-7433-441b-a16a-010fb19e3c78",[222,3583,1312,1306],{"_key":3588,"_type":48,"children":3589,"markDefs":3593,"style":89},"cf67bcb3f950",[3590],{"_key":3591,"_type":52,"marks":3592,"text":1865},"1576cc088b1c0",[63],[],{"_key":3595,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3596},"1cd482fb9a7f",[3597,3599,3601],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3598},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3600},[214,902,1230,2600],{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3602},[222,3603,1853,1331],"75.7%",{"_key":3605,"_type":48,"children":3606,"markDefs":3610,"style":89},"90ae1bb14a33",[3607],{"_key":3608,"_type":52,"marks":3609,"text":1884},"4f4589a8bfcb0",[63],[],{"_key":3612,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3613},"8da919c0d875",[3614,3616,3618],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3615},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3617},[214,2687,3124,294],{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3619},[222,3620,1262,2375],"77.2%",{"_key":3622,"_type":48,"children":3623,"markDefs":3627,"style":89},"93803a26a7b2",[3624],{"_key":3625,"_type":52,"marks":3626,"text":1904},"732f91eed6200",[63],[],{"_key":3629,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3630},"706d88e581ac",[3631,3633,3637],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3632},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3634},[214,3635,3064,3636],"77.9%","13.9%",{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3638},[222,3583,1351,1239],{"_key":3640,"_type":48,"children":3641,"markDefs":3645,"style":89},"c149313ffdf2",[3642],{"_key":3643,"_type":52,"marks":3644,"text":1924},"9241fbbb0b2e0",[63],[],{"_key":3647,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3648},"209fd392459a",[3649,3651,3655],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3650},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3652},[214,3653,3654,1403],"78.3%","9.5%",{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3656},[222,2285,2533,1973],{"_key":3658,"_type":48,"children":3659,"markDefs":3663,"style":89},"bd37f3500c30",[3660],{"_key":3661,"_type":52,"marks":3662,"text":1944},"db5ee33ff5c1",[63],[],{"_key":3665,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3666},"588ed75e34e2",[3667,3669,3671],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3668},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3670},[214,820,1253,2109],{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3672},[222,2109,1874,1072],{"_key":3674,"_type":48,"children":3675,"markDefs":3679,"style":89},"b9fb054c060f",[3676],{"_key":3677,"_type":52,"marks":3678,"text":1964},"d5388d389d7e0",[63],[],{"_key":3681,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3682},"cc91aa03c405",[3683,3685,3688],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3684},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3686},[214,644,2091,3687],"16.4%",{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3689},[222,3690,2071,2067],"73.8%",{"_key":3692,"_type":48,"children":3693,"markDefs":3697,"style":89},"31aa324ebf6d",[3694],{"_key":3695,"_type":52,"marks":3696,"text":1985},"9d0b0c13f3350",[63],[],{"_key":3699,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3700},"e64c307aa52a",[3701,3703,3707],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3702},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3704},[214,3705,3706,341],"67.8%","16.6%",{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3708},[222,3709,341,1241],"67.1%",{"_key":3711,"_type":48,"children":3712,"markDefs":3716,"style":89},"e6f21406b0ef",[3713],{"_key":3714,"_type":52,"marks":3715,"text":2005},"d41d2812206b0",[63],[],{"_key":3718,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3719},"3585c8c88730",[3720,3722,3725],{"_key":3575,"_type":204,"cells":3721},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":3581,"_type":204,"cells":3723},[214,3724,2263,971],"62.5%",{"_key":3585,"_type":204,"cells":3726},[222,2128,2628,224],{"_key":3728,"_type":48,"children":3729,"markDefs":3733,"style":172},"a67fb7d4c1ad",[3730],{"_key":3731,"_type":52,"marks":3732,"text":1738},"28bcf8e4ff4c",[],[],{"_key":3735,"_type":48,"children":3736,"markDefs":3740,"style":89},"11c07967e242",[3737],{"_key":3738,"_type":52,"marks":3739,"text":3562},"0639917971a20",[195],[],{"_key":3742,"_type":48,"children":3743,"markDefs":3747,"style":89},"77b84587cfed",[3744],{"_key":3745,"_type":52,"marks":3746,"text":1838},"e6f78c88b0060",[63],[],{"_key":3749,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3750},"410add81c18f",[3751,3753,3756,3759,3762,3765,3767,3770,3772,3774,3777],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3752},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3754},[682,3755,2368,1234],"83.0%",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3757},[687,3758,1482,1355],"82.1%",{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3760},[693,3761,1262,2411],"80.7%",{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3763},[700,3764,3654,2174],"74.8%",{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3766},[707,2335,1917,1403],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3768},[714,3769,1288,1322],"82.7%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3771},[722,1897,1917,2773],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3773},[727,3690,1403,3417],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3775},[734,3776,1917,2394],"79.1%",{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3778},[741,947,2017,2117],{"_key":3780,"_type":48,"children":3781,"markDefs":3785,"style":89},"ea2de5a21745",[3782],{"_key":3783,"_type":52,"marks":3784,"text":1865},"3baeeae505520",[63],[],{"_key":3787,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3788},"7317f7563e94",[3789,3791,3794,3796,3798,3800,3802,3804,3807,3809,3811],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3790},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3792},[682,3793,866,1277],"91.5%",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3795},[687,820,1416,1355],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3797},[693,2605,1284,2954],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3799},[700,2128,1258,1495],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3801},[707,898,1997,2104],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3803},[714,2335,1322,2456],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3805},[722,3806,2856,303],"73.3%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3808},[727,325,1618,2181],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3810},[734,351,2375,1084],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3812},[741,3813,1253,2600],"76.8%",{"_key":3815,"_type":48,"children":3816,"markDefs":3820,"style":89},"18c22a0fd112",[3817],{"_key":3818,"_type":52,"marks":3819,"text":1884},"5026faf86cfc0",[63],[],{"_key":3822,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3823},"1842b2683bd8",[3824,3826,3828,3831,3834,3837,3839,3842,3845,3847,3850],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3825},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3827},[682,3690,3084,1072],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3829},[687,3830,1234,3687],"73.5%",{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3832},[693,902,1917,3833],"18.3%",{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3835},[700,3836,1331,2652],"69.6%",{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3838},[707,730,1253,2224],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3840},[714,3841,2214,1416],"80.0%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3843},[722,3844,2214,3833],"72.9%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3846},[727,3428,2533,1250],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3848},[734,3849,2533,723],"70.0%",{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3851},[741,3830,2701,3852],"19.6%",{"_key":3854,"_type":48,"children":3855,"markDefs":3859,"style":89},"89e973831ae3",[3856],{"_key":3857,"_type":52,"marks":3858,"text":1904},"7c64d102918c0",[63],[],{"_key":3861,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3862},"18d05aa00cb0",[3863,3865,3867,3870,3873,3875,3877,3880,3883,3886,3888],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3864},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3866},[682,2306,2411,1318],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3868},[687,3869,2405,2501],"84.5%",{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3871},[693,3872,2533,3417],"77.5%",{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3874},[700,3806,2067,2954],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3876},[707,3583,2903,2456],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3878},[714,3879,1312,2214],"81.3%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3881},[722,3882,2439,3124],"81.7%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3884},[727,3885,1934,225],"75.8%",{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3887},[734,1026,1253,2954],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3889},[741,403,2307,894],{"_key":3891,"_type":48,"children":3892,"markDefs":3896,"style":89},"f229cbb09da3",[3893],{"_key":3894,"_type":52,"marks":3895,"text":1924},"35323cf6224a0",[63],[],{"_key":3898,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3899},"a605858f1109",[3900,3902,3905,3907,3910,3912,3914,3917,3920,3922,3924],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3901},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3903},[682,3904,2487,2856],"83.3%",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3906},[687,1062,1322,1239],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3908},[693,3909,3124,3417],"76.7%",{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3911},[700,3764,1474,1403],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3913},[707,874,1997,3636],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3915},[714,3916,1301,3084],"81.8%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3918},[722,3919,1288,2533],"80.8%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3921},[727,970,1416,3636],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3923},[734,3776,1934,880],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3925},[741,3926,2491,2067],"80.3%",{"_key":3928,"_type":48,"children":3929,"markDefs":3933,"style":89},"ad2105c51baa",[3930],{"_key":3931,"_type":52,"marks":3932,"text":1944},"b4519c33837e0",[63],[],{"_key":3935,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3936},"908536b99bf0",[3937,3939,3941,3944,3946,3949,3951,3953,3956,3958,3960],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3938},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3940},[682,3916,2368,1284],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3942},[687,3943,2510,1262],"79.7%",{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3945},[693,1062,2276,2456],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3947},[700,3948,1271,870],"75.0%",{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3950},[707,3872,2379,2084],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3952},[714,3776,1284,1284],{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3954},[722,3955,2903,2856],"82.6%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3957},[727,938,1181,294],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3959},[734,3813,2362,1336],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3961},[741,3653,2903,2375],{"_key":3963,"_type":48,"children":3964,"markDefs":3968,"style":89},"b305024004bc",[3965],{"_key":3966,"_type":52,"marks":3967,"text":1964},"929251b146300",[63],[],{"_key":3970,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":3971},"b3e1e5e44ab1",[3972,3974,3977,3979,3981,3984,3987,3990,3994,3996,3998],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":3973},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":3975},[682,3976,3976,3976],"–",{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":3978},[687,3879,2536,1262],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":3980},[693,296,959,2449],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":3982},[700,3983,303,303],"68.3%",{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":3985},[707,3986,1420,939],"67.2%",{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":3988},[714,3690,3989,2084],"18.1%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":3991},[722,3992,3993,3064],"72.3%","18.5%",{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":3995},[727,2500,2600,1075],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":3997},[734,696,2954,717],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":3999},[741,938,1301,894],{"_key":4001,"_type":48,"children":4002,"markDefs":4006,"style":89},"117304829e3c",[4003],{"_key":4004,"_type":52,"marks":4005,"text":1985},"5bce683f05a20",[63],[],{"_key":4008,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":4009},"1ecc17b0d5cd",[4010,4012,4014,4016,4018,4020,4022,4025,4027,4029,4031],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":4011},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":4013},[682,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":4015},[687,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":4017},[693,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":4019},[700,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":4021},[707,1913,567,2652],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":4023},[714,4024,1093,1231],"64.2%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":4026},[722,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":4028},[727,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":4030},[734,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":4032},[741,3709,1478,1295],{"_key":4034,"_type":48,"children":4035,"markDefs":4039,"style":89},"1477151c8239",[4036],{"_key":4037,"_type":52,"marks":4038,"text":2005},"51b16cd6d1940",[63],[],{"_key":4041,"_type":200,"markDefs":12,"rows":4042},"4b2fe68d6e6e",[4043,4045,4047,4049,4051,4053,4055,4058,4060,4062,4064],{"_key":1398,"_type":204,"cells":4044},[206,3577,3578,3579],{"_key":1462,"_type":204,"cells":4046},[682,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1465,"_type":204,"cells":4048},[687,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1469,"_type":204,"cells":4050},[693,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1472,"_type":204,"cells":4052},[700,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1476,"_type":204,"cells":4054},[707,2374,3852,462],{"_key":1480,"_type":204,"cells":4056},[714,3724,4057,1308],"21.2%",{"_key":1484,"_type":204,"cells":4059},[722,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1488,"_type":204,"cells":4061},[727,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1493,"_type":204,"cells":4063},[734,3976,3976,3976],{"_key":1497,"_type":204,"cells":4065},[741,2400,875,1093],{"_key":4067,"_type":48,"children":4068,"markDefs":4073,"style":89},"32551cbd9f46",[4069],{"_key":4070,"_type":52,"marks":4071,"text":4072},"8686f78e10bf0",[195],"Data only shown if sample size is more than 50 respondents.",[],"2023\u002F06\u002F12","This year we used our 2023 Developer Survey to ask 90,000 developers & technologists how they feel about AI\u002FML. We go deep into the data to understand the nuances in sentiment and use.",{"_type":4077,"asset":4078},"image",{"_ref":4079,"_type":4080},"image-518be8133635bcf523e4d6f6c3ebe3dbb0ff9152-365x275-svg","reference","2023-06-12T14:26:00.000Z",{"_type":10,"current":4083},"developer-survey-sentiment-ai-ml",[4085,4103],{"_createdAt":4086,"_id":4087,"_rev":4088,"_type":4089,"_updatedAt":4090,"description":4091,"slug":4100,"title":4102},"2025-04-14T10:12:56Z","22b7727b-da8a-4324-884a-9a7d399aa2df","JfoWZSLIstjPUpetad9kUn","blogTag","2025-04-14T10:13:47Z",[4092],{"_key":4093,"_type":48,"children":4094,"markDefs":4099,"style":89},"8fd652e18302",[4095],{"_key":4096,"_type":52,"marks":4097,"text":4098},"2256eb09fbbb",[],"Where we explore future of collective knowledge sharing through experiments.",[],{"_type":10,"current":4101},"labs","Labs",{"_createdAt":4104,"_id":4105,"_rev":4106,"_type":4089,"_updatedAt":4107,"slug":4108,"title":4110},"2025-04-14T11:55:55Z","e84a4b4f-9299-48c7-80c7-6f00c9709042","NO4mf4WFgUc3uKBcLpP1CO","2025-04-14T11:55:59Z",{"_type":10,"current":4109},"labs-research","Labs: Research","Developer sentiment around AI\u002FML (2023)",true,[4114,4120,4126,4132],{"_id":4115,"publishedAt":4116,"slug":4117,"sponsored":12,"title":4119},"28e560af-f0aa-4d46-bd90-f435ad604aa7","2026-06-26T14:00:27.102Z",{"_type":10,"current":4118},"paging-charity-how-can-engineering-leaders-avoid-becoming-bond-villains","Paging Charity! How can engineering leaders avoid becoming Bond villains?",{"_id":4121,"publishedAt":4122,"slug":4123,"sponsored":12,"title":4125},"4b22c2a3-3779-4966-93eb-5230391dbdce","2026-06-23T14:08:58.595Z",{"_type":10,"current":4124},"your-ai-shipped-a-backend-that-boots-that-is-the-whole-problem","Your AI shipped a backend that boots. That is the whole problem.",{"_id":4127,"publishedAt":4128,"slug":4129,"sponsored":12,"title":4131},"5cf362e1-fe7b-45af-b69c-914731c6a052","2026-06-23T14:00:00.000Z",{"_type":10,"current":4130},"the-2026-developer-survey-is-now-open-for-human-developers-only","The 2026 Developer Survey is now open (for human developers only)!",{"_id":4133,"publishedAt":4134,"slug":4135,"sponsored":12,"title":4137},"30b995f7-7cb9-4dd8-bf71-d0685940a32b","2026-06-19T14:00:00.000Z",{"_type":10,"current":4136},"dispatches-from-o-reilly-from-capabilities-to-responsibilities","Dispatches from O'Reilly: From capabilities to responsibilities",{"data":4139,"sourceMap":-1},{"count":4140,"lastTimestamp":12},0]